Human Resources News & Insights

Automatic enrollment may hurt employee retirement savings

Auto-enrollment in retirement plans may not contribute to employee retirement savings as much as once thought. Why?

Companies appear to reduce their 401(k) match when they adopt automatic enrollment, according to a recent study by Urban Institute.

Reason: Higher participation rates mean increased costs for employers that have to match worker contributions.

The statistical model developed by the Urban Institute reveals that match rates are 7% lower on average for employers that adopt auto-enrollment.

Has your company considered reducing its 401(k) match to adopt automatic enrollment? Let us know in the Comments Box below.

Print Friendly

Subscribe Today

Get the latest and greatest Human Resources news and insights delivered to your inbox.


  1. Agreed. With the combination of a transient employee population who would be forced to take a distribution if they did not accumulate $1000 in their account before termination and the increased costs associated with more participants – auditors for Form 5500, etc., my company is sticking to just keeping a good match – not auto enrollment.

  2. Michaelene says:

    I agree with Artie, however our company has not given a match at all. This is one reason why we have such a low participation.

    Automatically enrolling people in the 401k without a match is unpopular, to say the least.

  3. We suspended our match but had nothing to do with auto enrollment. That was actually working out pretty well until the match was suspended “due to the economy”. We are trying to get it reinstated.

    ARTie: I always thought that the point was to get MORE participants….no????

  4. We added auto enrollment and 3.5% company match at the same time. Before auto enrollment we had NO company match.

Speak Your Mind