How much does a bad hire really cost? You might be surprised
December 8, 2011 by Tim GouldPosted in: Hiring, In this week's e-newsletter, Latest News & Views, Management, References
Even the best companies make a personnel mistake once in a while. But here’s a shocker: More than two thirds of firms in a recent survey said they’d suffered through a bad hire this year.
A new CareerBuilder survey revealed that 68% of employers were affected by a bad hire in the past year — about the same number as 2010.
The worst part: Bad hires are expensive.
Forty percent of employers reported that a new hire typically costs $1,000 or less; 34% said between $1,001 and $5,000, and 27% put that number at more than $5,000.
But the bad hires can significantly affect an organization’s bottom line. Given productivity problems and other factors, here’s what poll participants said their hiring mistake cost:
- More than $25,000 — 41%, and
- More than $50,000 — 25%.
Why do companies make bad hires? A rushed decision was the top reason companies gave for making a bad hire, but the survey found that there’s not often an easy explanation. Some alternatives:
- Needed to fill the job quickly — 38%
- Not sure; sometimes you make a mistake — 34%, and
- Didn’t check references — 11%.
And another 21% cited “insufficient talent intelligence,” whatever that might be.
What are the effects of a bad hire? Nine percent of the survey respondents said bad hires result in legal issues and 11% said they result in fewer sales. Other ill effects:
- Lower productivity – 41%,
- Lost time to recruit and train another worker — 40%,
- Cost to recruit and train another worker — 37%,
- Employee morale negatively affected — 36%, and
- Negative impact on client solutions — 22%.
The survey was conducted among 2,696 employers between Aug. 16 and Sept. 8 of this year.
Tags: bad hires, CareerBuilder, surveys
HRMorning.com delivers the latest HR news once a week to the inboxes of over 200,000 HR professionals.
follow us on Twitter
join our group on Facebook

