Human Resources News & Insights

Surprise recession byproduct: More employee loyalty (for some)

Recent research shows you and your company have a once-in-decade chance to build the type of worker loyalty that employers dream of.

The research was conducted by Kelly Services, Inc, between October 2009 and January 2010 — in the teeth of the recession. It essentially asked 134,000 people to describe their level of loyalty to their employers, and how that level had changed with the dire economy. Here’s how the employees responded:

  • 27% said their level of loyalty to their employers had gone up as a result of how the employers treated workers during the tough times — and not necessarily because of increases in pay and benefits.
  • 10% said employer reaction and treatment of employees during tough times had lessened loyalty to the company.
  • 63% said their level of loyalty stayed the same.

The apparent lesson: Employees sympathize that times are difficult and employers have to make tough choices. Employees don’t sympathize when they perceive that companies are taking advantage of the times to mistreat workers who, because of the job market, are afraid to look elsewhere.

The bottom line: The job market will get better. And when it does, companies that handled employee relations with integrity will have the edge.

Subscribe Today

Get the latest and greatest Human Resources news and insights delivered to your inbox.
  • Julia

    This is the reaction we have seen in our employees. Being in the Detroit metro area, most people know someone who is out of a job, therefore are quite happy to still have employment. Everyone had had to take on more, but still finding job satisfaction.

  • Merlynn Bertini

    My question would be–what was the level of loyalty for those employees indicating “stayed the same”? If that level was not high, then the results of this survey leave much to be desired. What many of my peers have told me is that some (in some cases all) of their management have taken the position that “employees should be greatful they have a job”. I would be curious to see how well this “loyalty” continues when the economy improves.

  • Debbie K

    Realistically Julia, it’s more like employment satisfaction. But that’s okay too.

  • Jason

    I don’t see the point in this article.

    “The bottom line: The job market will get better. And when it does, companies that handled employee relations with integrity will have the edge.”

    Any company that handles it’s employee relations with integrity will always have an edge regardless to the economy.

  • JMG

    The cited data actually is an indictment of unenlighted employers – the 73% of them who failed to improve employee loyalty. And “stayemployment” should not be confused with employee loyalty; it’s a reflection of the economy. Given a better opportunity, at least the 73% of 134K employees will move in a heartbeat.

  • Martin

    Nothing like fear created by a socialist zealot president and his minions of economic destruction in places run by these people for so long – like Detroit to gain loyalty for even more destructive social programs and government intrusion into all aspects of your lives.

    It won’t be long before we all are working for the government….or just getting handouts – wait until those 16,500 new IRS Agents hired from the Acorn or SEIU ranks start knocking at your door to fine and arrest you for not having health insurance…..and your personal IRS information being dispensed by the DHHS who has no mandate to secure it once released to them.

    Only a fool believes more government is better….lot of fools in Detroit obviously what a cesspool or corruption and waste that city is…just level it. Loyalty? Won’t matter much in another month or so….we’ll all be sucking air….. this economic situation is contrived to maintain unemployment at 10% to curry favor with a constant bunch of displaced people who will rely on government for 100% of everything….. the country is lost…..Detroit is the rusting icon of socialism in this country.

  • Marie

    Is it loyalty or is it not having any other options? I think the truth will be learned once jobs become available–will people stay put (loyalty) or will they move on?

  • Jason

    Loyalty is earned by employers who treat thier employees right! Not by the lack of other opportunities.

  • http://HRmorning Jim

    Martin, What a bunch of ridiculous garbage. Hate filled ignorant nonsense. Grow Up!

  • Milan Moravec

    Employee loyalty is dead: Long live the new employee loyalty. Public and private organizations are into a phase of creative disassembly where constant reinvention and adjustments are constant. Hundreds of thousands of jobs are being shed by Chevron, NUMI, Wells Fargo Bank, HP, Starbucks etc. and the state, counties and cities. Even solid world class institutions like the University of California Berkeley are firing staff, faculty and part-time lecturers. Estimates are that the State of California may jettison 47,000 positions.

    Yet many employees, professionals and faculty cling to old assumptions about one of the most critical relationship of all: the implied, unwritten contract between employer and employee.

    Until recently, loyalty was the cornerstone of that relationship. Employers promised job security and a steady progress up the hierarchy in return for employees’s fitting in, performing in prescribed ways and sticking around. Longevity was a sign of employeer-employee relations; turnover was a sign of dysfunction. None of these assumptions apply today. Organizations can no longer guarantee employment and lifetime careers, even if they want to.

    Organizations that paralyzed themselves with an attachment to “success brings success’ rather than “success brings failure’ are now forced to break the implied contract with employees – a contract nurtured by management that the future can be controlled.

    Jettisoned employees are finding that the hard won knowledge, skills and capabilities earned while being loyal are no longer valuable in the employment market place.

    What kind of a contract can employers and employees make with each other? The central idea is both simple and powerful: the job or position is a shared situation. Employers and employees face market and financial conditions together, and the longevity of the partnership depends on how well the for-profit or not-for-profit continues to meet the needs of customers and constituencies. Neither employer nor employee has a future obligation to the other. Organizations train people. Employees develop the kind of security they really need – skills, knowledge and capabilities that enhance future employability.

    The partnership can be dissolved without either party considering the other a traitor. Historical loyalty is dead – get used to it. Long live the new loyalty