We want to enter into a separation agreement with a departing employee. What should we include to make sure it holds up in court?
Quick Answer
A separation agreement is typically a complex legal document that incorporates a variety of components addressing topics such as date of termination, benefits, references, severance payment, release of claims, confidentiality, non-disparagement and return of company property.
To hold up in court, the agreement must be supported by adequate consideration, and it must be clear that the employee entered into it freely and voluntarily. The agreement should be written using language that is clear and understandable to the departing employee, and the employee should be given adequate time to consider it before signing.
If the departing employee is 40 or older, special requirements apply (see key takeaways below).
Legal Perspective
Fuller Law Group
San Diego, California
If a former employee challenges the validity of a separation agreement (and the important release of claims in that document), the usual theory is that they did not enter the agreement “knowingly and voluntarily,” says employment law attorney David Monks (dmonks@fullerlawgroup.co) of Fuller Law Group P.C. in San Diego, California.
Taking the air out of that argument requires using proper language in the agreement and a proper process for presenting the agreement to the employee.
- Use plain English. Words like “therein,” “heretofore,” and “said” (instead of “such”) are distracting and unhelpful.
- Be concise. You should be able to get everything you want with four to six pages.
- Give something of value. For a valid contract, each party must get valuable consideration. For the employee, that is typically money that they are not already entitled to receive. In other words, do not hold final earned wages hostage in order to compel the employee to sign the release.
- In the section for releasing claims, clearly and broadly describe the kinds of claims being released. It helps to include references to specific federal and state laws that are commonly part of employee lawsuits, such as Title VII of the Civil Rights Act, the Americans with Disabilities Act, the Age Discrimination in Employment Act (ADEA) (for employees aged 40 and over), and similar state laws.
- Identify the kinds of claims that are not released. These can vary from state to state, but generally an employee, in a severance agreement, cannot release claims for worker’s compensation benefits, unemployment benefits and disability benefits.
- Include a provision in which the employee waives the benefit of a law that limits the scope of releases. Some states, like California (Civil Code section 1542), have laws that limit the scope of a release to include only claims currently known to the employee. For the release agreement to encompass unknown potential claims as well, the employee must specifically waive their rights under that law.
- Give the employee ample time to consider the severance offer and terms. Evidence of duress or coercion will seriously harm the employer’s ability to enforce the separation agreement. For a release of age-discrimination claims under the ADEA, an employee must receive 21 days to consider signing the agreement and then seven days to revoke their consent. For releases by employees under age 40, it’s a good idea to give at least five days to consider and two days to revoke. Check for specific requirements in your state.
- If the employee’s primary language is not English, have the agreement translated into their primary language.
A solid release agreement will give your company peace of mind. It’s worth the investment of time to ensure that it is as good as it can be.
Relevant Case Law
Hallmark Cards, Inc. v. Murley
Reddinger v. SENA Severance Pay Plan
Pucilowski v. Spotify, USA, Inc.
HR Insight
MotoLease Funding LLC
Los Angeles, California
Include all the details of the agreement, says Roz Gamble, VP of Corporate Operations & HR. For example, specify the date of mutual separation, and detail all monies owed including hours worked, OT, holiday pay, accrued vacation pay, and expense reimbursement.
In addition, include a section on known and unknown claims as well as a confidentiality agreement and a mutual non-disparaging agreement. Also, if appropriate, include a section from the employee handbook regarding any applicable violation.
Raphael Health Care LLC
Columbus, Ohio
Separation agreements are legal documents and should be reviewed by an employment law attorney, says HR Manager Margaret Hawkins.
A separation agreement sets out the contractual understanding between the employer and the separated employee. If severance is involved, make sure that you provide the appropriate number of days to accept, sign and revoke the agreement. Make sure to adjust time frames for employees over and under the age of 40. Ensure the agreement contains all separation details, including severance amount, has a confidentiality clause and is explicit in stating that the employee is giving up the right to take legal action against the company by signing the agreement.
Clear HR Solutions
Allentown, Pennsylvania
A severance agreement is a contractual agreement where an employer pays an exiting employee in exchange for the release of future claims against an employer, explains VP of HR Jackie Plunkett. Due to the nature of the agreement, it is wise to have an employment attorney review a template annually to ensure the proper laws are cited.
There are differences in agreements depending on the age of the employee and whether the severance is from a reduction in force (RIF) or not. For this reason, you would have four templates:
- under 40 non-RIF
- over 40 non-RIF
- under 40 RIF, and
- over 40 RIF.
Each would have different consideration periods (seven to 45 days, depending on the agreement in accordance with OWBPA).
Agreements for those over 40 would include ADEA acknowledgments and RIF agreements for those over 40 would include a schedule of all impacted workers.
The Cost of Noncompliance
College pays $4M to former president to settle severance agreement dispute
College of DuPage
Who was involved: The College of DuPage, which is a community college in Illinois, and Robert Breuder, a former president at the college who was fired amid allegations of financial mismanagement.
What happened: In 2015, while Breuder was serving as the president at the College of DuPage, he allegedly misused campus resources and engaged in questionable financial practices. The college’s board decided to fire him, and it further decided to deny him severance benefits in the amount of $763,000. It said no severance was due because the severance agreement was entered into by previous members of the board. Breuder sued, and the college eventually agreed to settle.
Result: The college agreed to pay $4 million to settle the suit.
Info: Settlement agreement in Breuder v. Board of Trustees, 11/10/22.
Key Takeaways
- There must be adequate consideration, such as a severance payment, for the agreement to be enforceable.
- The consideration given to the employee cannot be something they are already entitled to, such as earned vacation time.
- All terms, and especially terms relating to waiver of claims, must be written in a way that is clear and understandable to the employee based on their level of education and experience.
- Make sure there is no coercion of lack of competency by the employee.
- There can be no fraud or misrepresentation by the employer.
- Include an integration clause to make it clear that this is the complete and final agreement between the parties.
- If the employee is 40 or older, make sure a waiver of age bias claims is knowing and voluntary; specifically say that the employee has rights under the federal Age Discrimination in Employment Act; advise the employee in writing to consult with an attorney before signing; give the employee at least 21 days to consider the offer; and give the employee seven days to revoke their signature. Also, a waiver of age claims cannot include rights and claims that might arise after it is executed.
- State laws may impose additional specific requirements.