What should we do if a worker files a harassment claim with the EEOC?
Quick Answer
Review the charge notice and follow its directions; gather relevant documents and respond to requests for information; and make sure no employee is punished for filing the charge or participating in the ensuing investigation.
Legal Perspective
Ogletree Deakins
Sacramento, California
Employers may consider the following steps if they receive a harassment charge from the EEOC, says employment law attorney Michael Nader (Michael.Nader@ogletree.com), of the firm Ogletree Deakins.
Consider these steps:
- Confirm the employee’s dates of employment, positions held and circumstances of departure, if applicable. Confirm similar information about the alleged harasser.
- Ensure HR and executives are aware of the charge. Thoroughly investigate the complaint.
- Tell all relevant departments and individuals to preserve all info, data and evidence related to the matter.
- Request a two-week extension of the charge response date.
- Assess the risk of a broader EEOC investigation into systemic harassment.
HR Insight
BM Associates Inc.
San Ramon, California
When a worker files a claim with the EEOC, the employer is notified, says HR Director Sruthi Ananthachari.
Whether you must attend an in-person meeting or provide a written response, you need to have all the facts of the case and supporting documents/evidence in your file. You need to present proof if required.
In one instance, I was asked to respond to a notice with details of the incident. The EEOC, after reviewing the response, decided there was no merit in the case and dismissed the claim.
In another situation after responding to the notice from the EEOC, I was advised to come in person for a meeting with the conciliation officer. This happens when the EEOC reviews the case and decides there is possible discrimination, and a meeting is required.
I was advised that I could bring an attorney to the meeting. The person representing the company should be able to make decisions on behalf of the company, including financial decisions. The conciliation officer also has the aggrieved employee in another room and makes an effort to mediate between the two parties.
In my experience, the conciliation officer was very helpful and committed to resolving the issue. You’re generally advised that the process could take a full day and you should be prepared to stay until the evening. In my case, Wi-Fi was available, and I was able to work at intervals throughout the day. If you get a notice from the EEOC:
- Get the facts of the case and document everything.
- Collect relevant documentation, including emails, text messages, WhatsApp and any other forms of communication like MS Teams, Slack, etc.
- Identify witnesses as needed and keep them briefed that there may be a need to meet with EEOC officials.
- Check your policies are consistent with the organizational practices and you do not find any violations. Have copies of your policy ready for documentation needs.
- Share the documents and discuss them with your employment law attorney to prepare a suitable response.
The Cost of Noncompliance
Title VII: Court issues $2.6M default judgment against company that ‘ghosted’ EEOC
Who was involved: Green JobWorks LLC, a staffing agency located in Hanover, Maryland, and 48 women.
What happened: After three women filed sex discrimination complaints, the EEOC sued on their behalf as well as a class of female applicants and employees who were adversely affected by similar discrimination. The suit alleged the company refused to hire the women for demolition positions and/or refused to assign those workers to such positions because of their sex. The women were allegedly subjected to remarks that indicated sexual bias. For example, one was allegedly told the company was “only hiring strong men and not women.” In an interview, another woman said she was told that “as a woman, she would have to prove herself” and that “although women can use jackhammers, [she should not] be surprised if the men at the job site gave her a broom.” After conciliation efforts failed, the EEOC sued – and the company purportedly ghosted the Commission, failing to respond to the lawsuit.
Result: A federal court in Baltimore entered a default judgment against Green JobWorks, establishing the company’s liability for its pattern or practice of sex discrimination,” the Commission announced. It awarded 48 female workers a total of $2,692,265 in monetary relief, consisting of:
- $665,566 for lost wages plus interest, and
- an additional $2,026,698 in punitive damages.
Info: Federal Court Awards More Than $2.6M to EEOC Against Green JobWorks LLC, 3/23/23.
Key Takeaways
- Check out the EEOC’s guidance on how to respond to an EEOC charge.
- Review the charge’s contents carefully to gain a full understanding of the allegations presented.
- Quickly notify key decision-makers.
- Determine whether defense of the charge may be covered by liability insurance.
- Follow the directions that the charge provides.
- Explore the possibility of participating in mediation to resolve the allegations.
- Gather and organize all relevant documentation.