She said she was paid less than males — so why did her bias lawsuit fall flat?
By

She said she was the only female doing the job, and that males were paid more. So why did her wage bias lawsuit fall flat?
A federal appeals court affirmed a lower court’s ruling against a female employee who raised a list of claims against her former employer, including wage discrimination, hostile work environment, constructive discharge and retaliation.
The plaintiff was Carina Gonzalez, whose employment tenure as a field technician for Englewood Lock and Safe ran from October 2017 through December 2018.
Several claims raised
In addition to alleging that she was paid less than male colleagues with comparable experience, Gonzalez said that she had to “beg” a colleague for an oil change for her company vehicle. She also complained that a male co-worker said “she would be a better man than him if she made it into fieldwork within six months.”
White Papers
Building an Adoption-Friendly Workplace: Benefits That Help Families Grow and Employees Stay
To support her assertion of a hostile environment, she said a female colleague once “touch[ed] her butt with [a] part sleeve” and asked her whether she watches porn.
She said things got so bad that she was forced to resign, adding that the employer retaliated against her by withholding money from her last paycheck and then harassing her by billing her for work items.
No reasonable jury …
At the trial court, the employer asked the court to take the matter out of a jury’s hands by granting it judgment as a matter of law. In other words, it told the trial judge no reasonable jury could find in Gonzalez’s favor based on all the evidence that was presented.
The trial judge agreed and issued a ruling for the employer.
On appeal, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit affirmed the lower court’s ruling.
Gonzalez said she was unfairly paid less than her male colleagues, but there was a fatal flaw in that assertion: Gonzalez, who filed her case without a lawyer, did not produce evidence relating to the pay that those male colleagues received.
The appeals court also let stand that trial judge’s determination that even if there was a pay disparity, there was no proof that the disparity was illegally based on sex.
Gonzalez was in fact given the opportunity to perform field work and received a significant raise as a result, the court said.
Oops
She also shot herself in the foot with her testimony that she wanted to work on safes and was only allowed to do so to “placate her.” Her own testimony was objective evidence that she got what she wanted, the court explained.
On her hostile work environment claim, the appeals court said there just was not enough evidence for a jury to say that the harassment she allegedly suffered was based on her sex.
To support her claim that things were so bad that she had to resign, Gonzalez said she was forced to serve a “customer with evident severe mental illness.” But another technician always accompanied her on those calls, and she did not otherwise show that things became objectively unbearable at work.
Finally, the appeals court agreed that the retaliation claim lacked merit. The record showed that the employer invoiced her for work items she did not return, and in any event there was nothing indicating that the invoice was sent in response to protected activity.
The lower court’s ruling was affirmed.
Beware of bias lawsuit
Employers need to be aware of the various weapons at hand for employees who believe that they have been underpaid based on their sex.
Here, the employee relied on Title VII, which bans compensation discrimination based on a number of protected categories, including sex.
Employees may also pursue relief for perceived pay discrimination based on sex under the federal Equal Pay Act, which requires equal pay for men and women who perform substantially equal jobs in the same establishment. In addition, states have their own laws addressing pay equity.
Gonzalez v. Englewood Lock & Safe, Inc., No. 23-1073 (10th Cir. 11/9/23).
Further Reading
Paid Sick Leave Notice Failures: Seattle Hotel, Staffing Agencies Pay $133K
A Seattle hotel operator and two staffing agencies will pay $133,026 to 11 workers to resolve alleged violations of the city’s paid sick leave ordinance and two other local laws protecting hotel employees. Investigators found evidence the companies: Payroll teams should check that pay stubs or other paid sick leave notices show leave earned, used […]
IC-Turned-W-2 Employee Sues for OT Pay: Why Court Backed Employer
A former employee who sometimes worked 18-hour days couldn’t convince the Sixth Circuit he was entitled to overtime pay. Here’s why the court backed the employer. From Offer Letter to Overtime Lawsuit After working with Cincinnati Bell for several years through an outside vendor, Loren Bennink joined the company as a W-2 employee in May […]
FMLA Intermittent Leave: 8 Questions HR Asks Most
Partial days, doctor’s notes, late arrivals. If intermittent FMLA leave keeps you guessing, these eight answers can help clear things up for HR.
Unpaid Pre-Shift Work Costs New Jersey Employer $725K
A New Jersey drywall installer must pay $725,000 after failing to pay 48 workers overtime for pre-shift work performed while they waited for transportation to job sites. The U.S. Department of Labor’s (DOL) Wage and Hour Division found P & B Partitions Inc. violated the Fair Labor Standards Act’s overtime rules. The company also refused […]
Connecticut Joins States Regulating Workplace AI: 7 Compliance Steps
Connecticut is putting employers on notice over workplace AI. Effective Oct. 1, 2026, SB 5 clarifies that Connecticut employers facing a discrimination claim can’t blame the artificial intelligence (AI) tools they use to make hiring, promotion, discipline or termination decisions. Other changes that kicked in the same day: And there’s more coming. The law’s second […]
USCIS Plans to Abolish 60-Day Grace Period for Certain Nonimmigrant Workers
On Sept. 11, the U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS) published a Notice of Proposed Rulemaking that, if adopted, would eliminate the 60-day grace period currently granted to most nonimmigrant workers in H-1B, H-1B1, E-1, E-2, E-3, L-1, O-1 or TN status who abruptly lose their positions. The grace period has been in place since […]