The 3 reasons why those candidates “No-Showed” you!
By

The conference room is set. The team prepped. Resume printed. Hiring managers are in the wings.
You’re ready! Wait. They’re five minutes late. Now 20 minutes. Well, shoot. You’ve been stood up by a No-Show candidate.
Again.
No-Show prospects are not only frustrating — they’re holding your company back and keeping you from taking yet another to-do off your list.
Why does this keep happening?
We work across hundreds of employers and dozens of industries and we can share that “no shows” are normal, yet they seem to happen to certain employers more than others. Let’s review some of the common factors across firms that seem to encounter no shows more frequently and what you can do about it.
You took too long
Your sales team probably knows that a lead is tremendously more likely to buy from you if 1) you’re the first to contact, and 2) you respond to activity within 15 minutes. Recruiting is similar, in a way.
Often the “no show” occurs because the candidate got another job or thinks they’re about to and they simply do a poor job at tying up the loose ends of the job hunt. Had you moved a little faster, you could have been the company making the offer. The time it takes you to first reach out to express interest and then schedule them to come in is the time other employers have to seal the deal.
Yes, it can be overwhelming to review hundreds of resumes while handling all the other responsibilities on your plate but you’ll be well-served to reach out to candidates quickly after they apply. It’s your best bet at making sure other employers are not developing relationships before you do and it makes the candidate feel wanted – which is important and also related to reason number three.
You have some image issues
“Not cool, Jared!” may be the entirety of the response you currently have when you see someone has written a poor review online about their work experience. Maybe a “I’m surprised to hear that” when a candidate sheepishly admits they’ve heard “some things” at industry events?
We’ve found significant correlation between poor employer reputation and first face to face interview “no shows.” People do a much deeper dive between their first call with you and when they’re coming in for a formal, sit down interview.
It’s not surprising that having happy team members post honest, positive feedback on the same boards can be an effective counter to put some concerned candidates minds at ease. We’ve also found that addressing these types of reputational issues head on during the first phone interview can minimize downstream “no shows,” especially when paired with the plan your company has implemented to address legitimate concerns.
You failed to sell them
Often, the “no show” occurs between the initial outreach and the first in-person interview. These early interactions are critical to not only when you’re evaluating a candidate’s potential to be successful in the role but also on how you sell them on what a great company they could be joining.
Speed not only helps with combating competitive offers, it also is one of the strongest genuine tools to help a candidate feel appreciated, valued, and wanted. This helps sell them on your company being the right firm for them.
Jobs are aplenty. Candidates, for now, are the sought-after resource. Are your initial touches properly balancing evaluating the candidate with building excitement around your opportunity? Have growth plans, benefits, success stories, exciting company developments and the right welcoming personalities lined up on those first initial connections to ensure you’ve got an eager (and early) candidate sitting across from you in the conference room at your next initial face to face interview.
While you may never be able to eliminate the dreaded “no show” if you act decisively, proactively manage any known reputational issues and not lose sight that from the start you have to “sell” as much as the candidate does, you’ll find your frustration rate from disappearing candidates fall dramatically.
Further Reading
70+ U.S. Companies Affected by Remote Worker Fraud: FBI Issues New Guidance
You’ve reviewed an applicant’s resume and conducted an interview. But how can you be sure the remote worker you’re planning to bring onto your payroll is who they claim to be? More hiring managers are finding out that a candidate who looks great on paper and interviews well may still be an impostor. In a […]
How Military Veterans Can Improve Hiring and Retention
As our nation celebrates Veterans’ Day, consider increasing your efforts to find, recruit and retain veterans to your organization. Try it now as a catalyst to hire and retain more veterans for years to come. The voluntary quit rate is about 2%, according to data from the Labor Department. But if companies continue to hire […]
Posting Ghost Jobs Could Be Illegal: 7 Better Ways to Recruit
Lawmakers in several states have proposed bills targeting Ghost Jobs – roles posted that don’t exist or employers don’t intend to fill immediately. One state attorney general is investigating the legality of posting Ghost Jobs and profiting from it. The numbers speak some truth behind lawmakers’ concerns. About 25% of employers that have an open […]
Why Candidates Apply Everywhere: 5 Tips for a Better Experience
Employers are seeing more “spray and pray” applications from job seekers who submit dozens, or even hundreds, of applications with limited assessment of whether each role is a strong fit. But this behavior is not just about impatient candidates. It is often a survival response to a hiring process that feels unclear, automated, and silent. […]
Skills Flipping: 3 Things HR Needs to Know About Job Candidates’ New Trick
Skills-based hiring calls for a new trend that will help employers and employees get hiring even closer to perfect: Job candidates are “skills flipping” — turning what might be considered negative traits into strengths. It’s causing employers to reconsider how that trait could work in the increasingly skills-based hiring environment. That’s reflected in job postings: […]
The Return of ‘Blue Book’ Hiring in the Age of AI-Enabled Candidates: 6 Critical Factors
Candidates are increasingly using AI to strengthen their applications, draft resumes and prepare for interviews. In remote hiring environments, some are even using AI to answer recruiters’ questions in real time or to have AI avatars attend interviews on their behalf. Used appropriately, AI can be a helpful tool. It can make it easier for […]