Skip to main content

EEOC Under Fire: States Sue to Block New Harassment Guidance

TD

By

Last updated May 20, 20243 min read
EEOC Under Fire: States Sue to Block New Harassment Guidance

As we predicted here a short time ago, newly released EEOC guidance on workplace harassment is facing a courtroom challenge that says some parts of the guidance are not valid.

Led by Tennessee, 18 states have sued the EEOC, calling the guidance “an attack on our constitutional separation of powers” and an “end-run around our constitutional institutions.”

In particular, the new suit objects to parts of the guidance relating to bathroom use and the use of preferred pronouns.

Near the end of April, the EEOC released a new harassment guidance document that newly outlined circumstances under which covered employers may – in its view – be held liable for unlawful harassment under Title VII.

Much of the guidance restated long-established principles relating to employer liability. But the guidance also broke some new ground as far as official EEOC guidance is concerned, particularly with respect to bathroom and pronoun use.

EEOC guidance addresses pronouns, bathroom use

Specifically, the guidance advised that prohibited sex-based discrimination under Title VII includes:

  • “repeated and intentional use of a name or pronoun [that is] inconsistent with the individual’s known gender identity (misgendering)”; and
  • “denial of access to a bathroom or other sex-segregated facility [that is] consistent with the individual’s gender identity.”

To support this position, the agency relied on the Supreme Court’s watershed 2020 ruling in Bostock v. Clayton County, in which the Court ruled that Title VII’s ban on sex discrimination prohibits employers from firing an employee based on their sexual orientation or sexual.

That ruling specifically said it was not addressing “bathrooms, locker rooms, or anything else of the kind.”

Despite that express reservation, the EEOC’s harassment guidance says Title VII applies to bathroom use.

Suit: EEOC went too far

The new suit asks a Tennessee federal district court to set aside the enforcement guidance document as unlawful. It says the guidance wrongfully purports to resolve “highly controversial and localized issues” that should reserved for Congress and the individual states to address.

The suit seizes on what it says is the narrowness of the Bostock decision, saying the ruling considered only whether Title VII bans employment termination based on one’s homosexual or transgender status.

“The Court [in Bostock] did not consider or decide questions about any other workplace activity or employment action,” the suit reads.

The suit says the new guidance imposes unrecoverable compliance costs on states while fundamentally infringing on their sovereignty.

5 claims for relief

The suit includes five specific claims for relief.

First, it asserts that the new harassment guidance document violates the Administrative Procedure Act (APA). It alleges that the guidance is contrary to Title VII and exceeds the EEOC’s statutory authority. The guidance expands Title VII beyond its text and structure, the suit says.

Second, the suit alleges violations of federal constitutional provisions relating to federalism and sovereign immunity as well as free speech and religious liberty.

Advertisement

Beacon from HRMorning: HR department of one? Beacon reads the law. You make the call. Try Beacon free.

By requiring the use of preferred pronouns, it alleges, the document unconstitutionally compels and restrains speech. The guidance also “treads on religious freedoms,” the suit adds.

The suit’s allegations relating to free speech and religious liberty are likely to become a strong focal point of the litigation as the case proceeds.

Third, the suit says the document is arbitrary and capricious in violation of the APA.

Fourth, it broadly alleges that the EEOC itself is “unconstitutionally structured” and says its rules are therefore void.

Finally, the suit presents a claim for a declaratory judgment.

Various relief is sought

As relief, the suing states want the court to:

  • Declare that the new guidance conflicts with Title VII
  • Set the new guidance aside
  • Declare that the EEOC lacked the authority to issue the document
  • Specifically declare that the document’s “gender-identity accommodation mandate” is arbitrary, capricious and invalid
  • Declare that Title VII does not ban employers from having showers, bathrooms and other living facilities that are separated by biological sex
  • Declare that Title VII does not force employers to use a transgender person’s preferred pronouns
  • Block enforcement of the guidance’s provisions relating to gender identity.

The states that joined Tennessee in the lawsuit are Alabama, Alaska, Arkansas, Georgia, Indiana, Iowa, Kansas, Kentucky, Mississippi, Missouri, Nebraska, Ohio, South Carolina, South Dakota, Utah, Virginia and West Virginia.

Filed underEmployment Law
Share

Further Reading

  • Paid Sick Leave Notice Failures: Seattle Hotel, Staffing Agencies Pay $133K

    A Seattle hotel operator and two staffing agencies will pay $133,026 to 11 workers to resolve alleged violations of the city’s paid sick leave ordinance and two other local laws protecting hotel employees. Investigators found evidence the companies: Payroll teams should check that pay stubs or other paid sick leave notices show leave earned, used […]

  • IC-Turned-W-2 Employee Sues for OT Pay: Why Court Backed Employer

    A former employee who sometimes worked 18-hour days couldn’t convince the Sixth Circuit he was entitled to overtime pay. Here’s why the court backed the employer. From Offer Letter to Overtime Lawsuit After working with Cincinnati Bell for several years through an outside vendor, Loren Bennink joined the company as a W-2 employee in May […]

  • Unpaid Pre-Shift Work Costs New Jersey Employer $725K

    A New Jersey drywall installer must pay $725,000 after failing to pay 48 workers overtime for pre-shift work performed while they waited for transportation to job sites. The U.S. Department of Labor’s (DOL) Wage and Hour Division found P & B Partitions Inc. violated the Fair Labor Standards Act’s overtime rules. The company also refused […]

  • Connecticut Joins States Regulating Workplace AI: 7 Compliance Steps

    Connecticut is putting employers on notice over workplace AI. Effective Oct. 1, 2026, SB 5 clarifies that Connecticut employers facing a discrimination claim can’t blame the artificial intelligence (AI) tools they use to make hiring, promotion, discipline or termination decisions. Other changes that kicked in the same day: And there’s more coming. The law’s second […]