Two great workers, but there’s only room for one: Who stays, who goes?

What should you do in this tricky scenario?  

HR manager Stu Capper had just finished his lunch when VP Karen Wheeler walked into his office. 

“Hi, Karen, you’re right on time for our meeting,” Stu said. “Have a seat.” 

“Hi, Stu,” Karen said, without much enthusiasm. 

“You don’t sound too happy,” Stu…