Transform Performance Management With 5 Strategic Moves
By

As organizations grapple with talent retention and employee satisfaction, it’s clear that once-a-year, rate-and-rank review systems no longer serve employees, managers, HR or the company.
It’s high time for companies to modernize their performance management processes, argues John Smith, senior director of SMB solutions within the global business applications division at Quisitive/emPerform.
Smith discussed performance management trends and helpful strategies for HR pros in an episode of HRMorning’s “Voices of HR” podcast.
What’s Trending
Voices of HR host Berta Aldrich highlighted that a common complaint that she hears among high-performing professionals is that they feel undervalued by their managers and employers. “Companies seem to be misfiring when it comes to talent identification, valuation and retention,” she commented.
White Papers
Building an Adoption-Friendly Workplace: Benefits That Help Families Grow and Employees Stay
Smith responded by reporting on trends that he’s observed:
- Customization: Companies are moving away from one-size-fits-all approaches, instead designing performance management systems tailored to their organizational needs.
- Continuous feedback: There’s a growing emphasis on integrating frequent coaching, one-on-one check-ins and regular feedback into the performance management process. “Just top-down saying, ‘This is your goal for the year and this is what you’re going to do’ — it’s not going to work across the board. It has to have a level of employee participation to make it work,” he said.
- Outcome-driven processes: Organizations are focusing on how performance management can drive tangible outcomes, such as employee engagement, compensation decisions, promotions and succession planning.
- Adapting to workplace changes: With shifting demographics, increased employee diversity and the rise of remote work, performance management systems need to evolve accordingly.
Strategies for Effective Performance Management
The thought of changing the way you do performance management can be terrifying — especially if you’re an HR department of one.
Here’s Smith’s advice for HR pros looking to revamp their processes to show they truly value their employees and want to develop them:
- Develop a clear vision: Articulate what you want to achieve with the new performance management system and communicate it to the C-suite.
- Set realistic short-term and long-term goals: Establish both immediate and future objectives for your performance management strategy and ensure they align with the organization’s overall strategy. This helps create a road map for implementation and allows for periodic assessments of progress. “A short-term goal, as it relates to improving a performance management process, could be, ‘We’re going to recommended quarterly check-ins. And that’s the big change we’re going to make.’ It doesn’t mean changing rating scales and throwing away content and competencies and redefining the whole objective structure. It means making a small change,” Smith said.
- Secure top-down support: Your management team and top-level executives need to be in agreement that an adjustment needs to be made to performance management before implementing any changes. This support is crucial for long-term success and sustainability of the new process.
- Implement gradual changes: Rather than overhauling the entire system at once, consider making smaller, incremental improvements. This approach allows for better adaptation and acceptance among employees and managers. “Are we somebody with an annual appraisal and [we’re] going to hop all the way over to no appraisal at all and no ratings? Probably not,” he said.
- Decouple performance and compensation conversations: Consider separating performance discussions from compensation decisions to allow for more meaningful performance-focused dialogue.
“Market equity, internal equity and performance are the three pillars of a successful compensation program. So performance on its own is one of the important pillars, and performance will always be a feeder into it. But compensation looks at other things as well, and so part of that is educating the high-performer that it isn’t just a direct link. It’s not just one for one. There are other factors at play when we, as an organization, look at merit and we look at the budgets for merit,” Smith said.
Don’t Forget to Assess
It’s important to follow up and regularly assess the effectiveness of implemented changes — what works and what doesn’t — and make adjustments as needed.
So two years after implementing Smith’s short-term goal example of trying quarterly check-ins, there should be a review of whether the check-ins are getting buy-in and if it’s even worth it to do a big annual review at the end of the year anymore.
Bottom line: HR must work toward creating more valuable, employee-centric performance management processes that align with both their organization’s goals and the evolving needs of the modern workforce.
Further Reading
Kind v. Nice: It Makes a Big Difference for Employee Feedback | 2-Minute Video
When it comes to giving employee feedback, there’s a difference between being kind and being nice. It’s an important distinction HR pros and front-line managers want to make. What’s Up in This Episode: Kind v. Nice In this episode of HRMorning’s 3-Point, Amy Baker, Managing Partner at Happy Humans Consulting LLC, explains the difference between […]
A Better Way to Give Employees Feedback Now | 2-Minute Video
Giving and receiving feedback can be difficult. Giving and receiving bad feedback is even worse. We’re not talking about negative evaluations. We’re talking about doing a bad job with any kind of performance or behavior conversation. What’s Up in This Episode: Feedback Redo In this episode of HRMorning’s 3-Point, Kathie Leslie, Owner of Kathryn Leslie, […]
Employees Have FOBO: 5 Factors to Manage the AI Anxiety
Many employees are struggling with AI in ways you didn’t even imagine. They have FOBO – fear of becoming obsolete. And that fear has the potential to paralyze them — making the possibility of becoming obsolete a reality. “AI has accelerated that shift over the past year: tasks are being automated and employees are watching […]
4 Ways Workplace Community Drives Collaboration, Innovation and Growth
Across industries, workforce conversations often begin with the candidate experience. Long-term success depends just as much on what happens after someone joins an organization. To build resilient teams, leaders need to create workplaces where people feel connected, supported, authentic and able to envision a future. A strong sense of workplace community can help turn a […]
7 Keys to Give Feedback That’ll Help Employees Grow
Most bosses want to give feedback that helps employees do better. Unfortunately, many give feedback that makes employees feel worse about themselves and their work. It can be so bad that employees feel the impact of feedback delivered badly for years. That’s not the kind of impression leaders want to make. Feedback Gone Bad More […]
Build the Relationships That Matter Most at Work | 2-Minute Video
When it comes to recognition, the person who gives it is just as important as the message. Sure, it’s important for the boss to recognize employees. But peer-to-peer recognition packs the most punch: Employee relationships matter most. What’s Up in This Episode: Building Better Relationships That’s based on research and observation from Awardco. In this […]