Character vs. skill: Which matters most in your organization?
By

For hiring managers, navigating the character and skills of potential candidates can be a real challenge.
Personality and character fit an individual to your business, brand and work culture, integrating them into teams that thrive on cooperation.
But skills matter too – candidates must possess the right hard and soft skills required for a job.
Character or personality is perhaps the more elusive component, not easily documented through work experience, qualifications and education. Skills are perhaps easier to assess, but can also be fickle and tough to quantify.
So, character vs skills, which should you focus on when hiring, and how?
Soft vs. hard skills
Skills can be divided into soft and hard skills. Hard skills are much easier to quantify and measure whereas soft skills somewhat blend into personality and character.
Hard skills refer to technical and practical skills. They’re usually documented through a candidate’s experience and education. An assessment of qualifications and job experience can reveal the technical skills required to succeed in those activities.
Soft skills are more interpersonal: communication, etiquette, time-keeping and teamwork.
In an analysis by Guy Berger, Ph.D, soft skills were more frequently in-demand than hard skills with communication topping the list at 57.9%. Teamwork and organization followed closely behind at 56.5% and 56.4% respectively.
Soft skills are tough to screen and delineate, with 60% of hiring managers stating that they find it hard to screen candidates effectively for soft skills. Research by PSI found that 67% of employers would hire candidates for strong soft skills even when hard skills were lacking.
The trouble is, soft skills are often self-reported, so without proper assessment, they’re notoriously hard to verify. It’s natural to make oneself seem professionally and socially desirable on CVs and job applications; this is where difficulties arise as hiring managers have to discern between social selling and reality.
Personality and character go deeper than 1-to-1 interactions and traditional interviews, psychometric assessments can analyze personality in an environment that is comfortable and natural for the candidate.
Test procedures are the best way to pierce the veil of social selling, helping you objectively understand candidates.
Hard skills for technical jobs
For jobs that involve a great deal of technical or practical work, hard skills are often the priority for hirers. Sometimes, you simply cannot be skilled at a task or procedure unless you’ve practiced it for thousands of hours.
Ariadne Labs showed that doctors and surgeons are often lacking in interpersonal soft skills, especially communication skills, something which has been echoed in public health research throughout the years.
Ultimately, though, there is no trade-off between hard and soft skills when it comes to being a doctor or surgeon – hard skills will always take some form of precedence.
In these cases, it’s crucial to discover how robust those hard skills are and how well they balance with soft skills.
Skills can be taught
Employers expect candidates to already possess both hard and soft skills but it’s important to not undermine the role of training. Candidates with significant hard skills but potentially lacking, or understated soft skills can be worth training instead of refraining from hiring them completely.
Similarly, hard skills can be learnt on the job and someone with evidently strong soft skills could pick up hard skills very quickly.
Soft skills for customer-facing jobs
Teamwork and work culture is changing with the increase in remote work and work-from-home setups, but many jobs still require personal communication between employees and customers, whether that’s via telephone call, email or Zoom.
Where ongoing communication is required, personality and character play a very important role in building and retaining rapport between businesses, brands and their customers and clients.
But, hiring candidates based on a stellar telephone manner comes with no guarantees that this will transfer onto real-life. Screening for personality and character is particularly important for customer or client-facing roles.
Psychometric results illustrate natural personality insights that are easily broken down, analyzed and compared to employment priorities.
Going the extra mile
Transparent, honest and hardworking candidates will usually be the ones to bridge gaps in their hard and soft skills, going the extra mile to ply themselves to the role.
Accountability in the Workplace: Developing and Engaging Employees in Times of Change
Conscientiousness, diligence and a transparent attitude are very important for roles that require ongoing development and independence.
Self-aware candidates may not possess the same level of hard and soft skills as others, but they will at least be aware of what they need to work on and may exceed the skills of other candidates if given time.
Analyzing these sorts of skills is tricky and likely requires psychometric or other personality testing.
Quick-starters vs. developers
If you’re looking for someone that can make a quick start then candidates with proactivity and pragmatism combined with a get-up-and-go attitude are ideal.
Strong all-rounders are likely to be flexible and willing to learn to maintain their diverse skill sets.
They make quick-starters that can be pitched straight into a job role with minimal training. At the same time, strong all-rounders may possess less scope for specialism or niche development.
Developing a test procedure ensures a transparent recruiting procedure that eliminates prejudices and ensures fairness.
Sophisticated psychometric testing goes beyond the bare aptitude metrics to uncover insights about self-awareness, responsibility, empathy and leadership. It’s the most accurate and fair means to assess candidates for almost any professional role.
Further Reading
70+ U.S. Companies Affected by Remote Worker Fraud: FBI Issues New Guidance
You’ve reviewed an applicant’s resume and conducted an interview. But how can you be sure the remote worker you’re planning to bring onto your payroll is who they claim to be? More hiring managers are finding out that a candidate who looks great on paper and interviews well may still be an impostor. In a […]
Post-Election Fallout: 2 Ways to Manage New Tension in the Workplace
With the midterms over, you’d probably like to put the occasional (or frequent?) contentious moments any election can cause behind you. But it’s not likely to end with the last vote cast. HR and other leaders often face a recurring challenge in post-election times: acknowledging and managing politically charged moments that can turn up tension […]
An ‘Insecurity Tax’ Could Hurt Retention: 4 Solutions to Keep Your Talent
The last decade of corporate churn might have revealed this surprising lesson: One of the biggest threats to retention isn’t compensation, remote work or even AI. It could be managerial insecurity. When leadership is rooted in a manager’s personal anxiety, organizational behavior becomes entirely predictable. Micromanagement, hoarding authority, avoiding constructive dissent, and making defensive decisions […]
Politics at Work: An Election-Season Toolkit for HR Leaders
Employers everywhere are bracing for one of the trickiest challenges of the year as the country goes through another contentious election season. Inflammatory political speech in the workplace is disruptive and can lead to a host of workplace issues ranging from frustration and fractured relationships to claims of harassment and workplace violence incidents. With increasing […]
Are You Keeping Workforce Data Longer Than You Need To?
When an employee leaves, HR closes the personnel file, processes the final paycheck, and shuts off system access. Copies of that employee’s information can remain in places HR does not manage: email archives, collaboration platforms, badge-access logs, fleet telematics systems, and the files of recruiting, payroll and benefits vendors. Some of those records have to […]
How Managers Are the Missing Link in Workforce Capability: 3 Solutions
Managers are the bridge between business strategy, day-to-day execution, and organizational growth. Understanding and developing workforce capability has always been central to that role. And for HR leaders, a manager’s ability to do that well impacts everything from internal mobility and succession planning to retention and workforce readiness. The challenge is that workforce capability is […]