No-Poach Recruiting Agreements Cost Employers $25.5 Million
By

Think it’s OK to agree with other employers not to recruit their employees if they won’t go after yours? Think again.
That kind of arrangement can get you into some legal trouble. Just ask a group of asset and wealth management companies that recently got hammered to the tune of $25.5 million for entering into such an agreement.
Handshake Deal: No Recruiting of Workers
The defendants in this case are big players in the asset and wealth management space. In fact, the three groups of defendants – referred to as the Mariner defendants, the American Century defendants and the Tortoise defendants – together manage nearly $305 billion in assets.
In 2008, a senior American Century employee took a job with Mariner and recruited other American Century employees to come with him. After that happened, American Century and Mariner entered into a secret agreement not to recruit or hire each other’s employees.
White Papers
Building an Adoption-Friendly Workplace: Benefits That Help Families Grow and Employees Stay
DOJ Enters the Picture
When the Department of Justice got wind of the agreement, it conducted an antitrust and conspiracy investigation. That investigation ultimately produced a non-prosecution agreement and an agreement by American Century to commit $1.5 million to affected employees.
A private suit filed against the group of asset management giants alleged that between March 2014 and March 2018, the defendants illegally conspired via the agreement to squelch competition by agreeing not to go after each other’s employees.
No-Poach Recruiting Agreements: What’s the Problem?
The problems with the agreement, the plaintiffs said, were that it:
- Diminished employee mobility
- Limited employee opportunities to negotiate for more favorable employment terms, and
- Artificially deflated the compensation of affected employees, and caused their wages to be lower than they would be in a competitive marketplace.
The class action suit, which included named plaintiffs Jakob Tobler and Michelle McNitt, specifically alleged two claims under the federal Sherman Act; a single state-law antitrust claim; a claim of tortious interference with business expectancy; and a single claim for unjust enrichment.
Mediation Leads to Settlement
A full-day mediation session in February of this year laid the groundwork for a settlement, and earlier this month, the plaintiffs’ lawyers submitted to the court an unopposed motion for final approval that explained the agreement’s specific terms.
The settlement class consists of employees who worked for one of the firms between 2012 and 2020. It excludes boards of directors as well as C-suite employees. The motion says there are 4,410 class members.
Under the agreement, the defendants paid $25.5 million into an escrow account. Of that total, $8.5 million will go toward attorneys’ fees, while about $396,000 is allocated for costs and expenses. That leaves an average estimated payment of $3,741.05 for each affected employee, the motion says.
Tobler and McNitt will each receive “service awards” of $15,000, the motion adds.
The specific amount awarded to other individual employees will depend on their duration of employment, when they were employed, and how much they earned.
Motion: This Is a Fair Deal
To boost its push for final approval of the agreement, the motion says:
- Lawyers for the plaintiffs have provided “excellent representation”
- The settlement was negotiated at arm’s length
- The settlement provides relief that is “fair, reasonable, and adequate,” and
- The settlement treats class members equitably.
Why This Matters to HR
On the surface, it may not seem like a terrible idea to enter into a mutual arrangement with other employers not to recruit each other’s employees. But in fact, it is exactly that: a terrible idea.
Why? These agreements wrongly stifle competition and violate federal antitrust laws, including the Sherman Act. As they did in this case, they can lead to government enforcement action as well as civil liability.
When it comes to finding and keeping the best employees, stick to the tried-and-true basics. These include:
- Be open, inclusive and transparent with respect to your recruitment practices.
- Know what it takes in terms of compensation to hire and retain top talent.
- Whenever possible, provide opportunities for professional and personal growth.
- Have an effective and comprehensive onboarding process.
- Assign mentors to employees.
- Encourage active feedback from employees; ask them about their level of job satisfaction and solicit suggestions for improvement.
Further Reading
Paid Sick Leave Notice Failures: Seattle Hotel, Staffing Agencies Pay $133K
A Seattle hotel operator and two staffing agencies will pay $133,026 to 11 workers to resolve alleged violations of the city’s paid sick leave ordinance and two other local laws protecting hotel employees. Investigators found evidence the companies: Payroll teams should check that pay stubs or other paid sick leave notices show leave earned, used […]
IC-Turned-W-2 Employee Sues for OT Pay: Why Court Backed Employer
A former employee who sometimes worked 18-hour days couldn’t convince the Sixth Circuit he was entitled to overtime pay. Here’s why the court backed the employer. From Offer Letter to Overtime Lawsuit After working with Cincinnati Bell for several years through an outside vendor, Loren Bennink joined the company as a W-2 employee in May […]
FMLA Intermittent Leave: 8 Questions HR Asks Most
Partial days, doctor’s notes, late arrivals. If intermittent FMLA leave keeps you guessing, these eight answers can help clear things up for HR.
How Military Veterans Can Improve Hiring and Retention
As our nation celebrates Veterans’ Day, consider increasing your efforts to find, recruit and retain veterans to your organization. Try it now as a catalyst to hire and retain more veterans for years to come. The voluntary quit rate is about 2%, according to data from the Labor Department. But if companies continue to hire […]
Unpaid Pre-Shift Work Costs New Jersey Employer $725K
A New Jersey drywall installer must pay $725,000 after failing to pay 48 workers overtime for pre-shift work performed while they waited for transportation to job sites. The U.S. Department of Labor’s (DOL) Wage and Hour Division found P & B Partitions Inc. violated the Fair Labor Standards Act’s overtime rules. The company also refused […]
Connecticut Joins States Regulating Workplace AI: 7 Compliance Steps
Connecticut is putting employers on notice over workplace AI. Effective Oct. 1, 2026, SB 5 clarifies that Connecticut employers facing a discrimination claim can’t blame the artificial intelligence (AI) tools they use to make hiring, promotion, discipline or termination decisions. Other changes that kicked in the same day: And there’s more coming. The law’s second […]