Pregnancy Discrimination Act: Was light-duty denial bias?
By

Unlike an Alabama district court, an appeals court couldn’t see the difference between injured workers who couldn’t lift more than 20 pounds and a pregnant worker who couldn’t lift 50, since none of them could meet the requirement to lift 100 pounds.
So it told the district court to take up the case again and determine whether the company’s reasons for treating the pregnant worker differently were legitimate based on the facts of the case or if they were a pretext for discriminating against her in violation of the Pregnancy Discrimination Act.
Forced to take unpaid leave while pregnant
Rural/Metro Corp., an emergency medical and fire services provider, told a pregnant emergency medical tech she was not eligible for light duty, after her doctor recommended she lift no more than 50 pounds for the duration of her pregnancy. The employer told her she’d instead have to take unpaid leave.
The EMT, Michelle Durham, pointed out that other EMTs who’d been injured while working had been moved to light duty to accommodate even more restrictive lifting limits. When the company held firm on denying her light duty, and then stopped scheduling her for work, she sued for discrimination under the Pregnancy Discrimination Act.
Rural/Metro Corp. asked for a summary dismissal, pointing to its light-duty policy, which it says states that only workers injured on the job were eligible for light duty, and another policy that allowed it to accommodate employees with disabilities on a case-by-case basis.
District court didn’t see pregnancy discrimination
A district court agreed that the circumstances of the other workers were different, and Durham had not established pregnancy discrimination.
It granted Rural’s motion and the ACLU of Alabama and, in November 2018, Birmingham attorney Heather Leonard appealed to the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit on behalf of Durham.
In returning the case to the district court, the appellate judges said “neither a non-pregnant EMT who is limited to lifting 10 or 20 pounds nor a pregnant EMT who is restricted to lifting 50 pounds or less can lift the required 100 pounds to serve as an EMT.”
The court found Rural/Metro’s policy might violate the Pregnancy Discrimination Act because the company could not justify the preferential treatment it afforded other EMTs.
Because none of the workers would meet the lifting requirement, the court said, “they are the same in their ‘inability to work’ as an EMT.”
While the case has not been decided as of May 2020, it provides a clear reminder to employers to make sure they follow the Pregnancy Discrimination Act’s mandate that they must accommodate pregnant workers on the same terms as other employees.
Further Reading
DOL’s Final Independent Contractor Rule: 12 Action Steps for HR and Payroll
On Nov. 19, 2026, the Department of Labor (DOL) announced its final independent contractor rule, and the clock is about to start ticking. Employers will have 60 days from its publication in the Federal Register to get ready. Most of the final rule matches the DOL’s February proposal. The final rule uses the economic-reality test […]
Minimum Wage Alert: Vermont Sets 2027 Rate at $14.91
Effective Jan. 1, 2027, Vermont’s minimum wage will increase from $14.42 to $14.91 an hour. That is a 49-cent increase, or $19.60 more per 40-hour workweek. And for tipped employees, the minimum wage will rise from $7.21 to $7.46 an hour. State law sets the tipped minimum at 50% of the full minimum wage, and […]
Connecticut Paid Sick Leave Expands to Nearly All Employers Jan. 1
Starting Jan. 1, 2027, employers with one or more employees in Connecticut must provide paid sick leave under Public Act 24-8. The current threshold for covered employers is 11 or more employees. Covered employers must allow covered employees to accrue one hour of paid leave for every 30 hours worked, up to 40 hours a […]
Paid Sick Leave Notice Failures: Seattle Hotel, Staffing Agencies Pay $133K
A Seattle hotel operator and two staffing agencies will pay $133,026 to 11 workers to resolve alleged violations of the city’s paid sick leave ordinance and two other local laws protecting hotel employees. Investigators found evidence the companies: Payroll teams should check that pay stubs or other paid sick leave notices show leave earned, used […]
IC-Turned-W-2 Employee Sues for OT Pay: Why Court Backed Employer
A former employee who sometimes worked 18-hour days couldn’t convince the Sixth Circuit he was entitled to overtime pay. Here’s why the court backed the employer. From Offer Letter to Overtime Lawsuit After working with Cincinnati Bell for several years through an outside vendor, Loren Bennink joined the company as a W-2 employee in May […]
FMLA Intermittent Leave: 8 Questions HR Asks Most
Partial days, doctor’s notes, late arrivals. If intermittent FMLA leave keeps you guessing, these eight answers can help clear things up for HR.