Good Employees Leave Bad Managers: 4 Biggest Problems
By

A company is only as good as the people it keeps.
And while the workplace has changed dramatically in the past 50 years, this hasn’t: Good employees don’t leave companies. Good employees leave bad managers.
Why Good Employees Leave
And they probably leave them more than we care to admit, if results of a study from the Adecco Group are accurate. Here are some telling numbers on the gaps between employee expectations and reality:
- 61% of managers think they support employees working arrangements; Just 43% of employees feel they do.
- 53% of managers feel they assess performance on outcomes, not hours; Only 36% of employees see it that way.
- 47% of managers claim they check on employee mental well-being; Only 33% of employees say that happens.
- 50% of managers feel they provide regular guidance and check-ins; 34% of employees say they actually get that.
Even if your front-line managers think they’re great, their employees may not feel that way. So, anyone who wants to be a good manager still has some work ahead of them.
To hear good employees tell the story, the problems they have with bad managers at work are less about the workload and more about style.
White Papers
Building an Adoption-Friendly Workplace: Benefits That Help Families Grow and Employees Stay
4 Management Styles That Drive Employees Crazy
So it’s critical to know the management styles that drive employees crazy. Here are the four of the biggest that’ll make good employees leave — and how to avoid them.
The worst managers:
1. Micromanage
There must come a point in the life of every good manager where they have to learn how to trust employees to do their jobs. It doesn’t mean not to hold them accountable – just to trust them.
Micromanagers are easy to spot because they are always asking: Where’s that report? What about this? How about that? Is this done? Have you pursued that? Did you call this person? Did you call that person? Did you do that? Here, let me show you how to do that.
This drives good people crazy – and it drives them away.
Better: Tell employees what to do, set them straight, be clear on the bottom line and the results that are needed. Then get out of the way!
2. Swing a Bat (Figuratively)
If you still have managers saying this – “Do It Or Else!” – you may have some decisions to make.
Yelling and screaming at employees, commonly called the baseball bat approach, should be banned. They are driving good people away. It’s just a matter of time.
Better: Ask employees to complete tasks. Guide and train them toward better ways to accomplish goals.
3. Use the Silent Treatment
Good employees always demand to know, “Where do I stand?” That’s why good communication and feedback are key.
It’s never good to say, “Kathy, if you haven’t heard from me until next year’s evaluation, please know in your heart that you’re a good employee.”
Translation: “Kathy, you’re doing OK, so I’m going to spend all of my time ignoring you and managing the crummy employees.”
Obviously, that’s not an engaging message of value or worth to Kathy. Kathy wants to do more than just be “OK.” She is going to be completely unfulfilled, and she is going to start finding greener pastures real soon.
Better: Schedule time for feedback throughout the year. Recognize and compliment what’s going well. Coach what’s not.
4. Treat Everyone the Same
Sure, consistency can buy morale – at times. And it can buy some degree of legal protection, depending on the situation. But under the law, equal opportunity never meant equal treatment.
When a manager treats good and bad employees the same, the wrong message is being sent.
Good employees soon realize that it doesn’t matter how much effort they put into their work, they’ll get treated same as every one else. So then they wonder, “What’s the difference?”
Reward good people for their behavior, or be prepared to replace them. It doesn’t have to be money, but that goes a long way. Be certain to recognize all good work — and reward the best.
Further Reading
3 ‘Learning Culture’ Fails and How HR Can Fix Them Before Gen Z Quits
As a leader, it is easy to become “snowblind” in the current business climate. We are bombarded daily by a slew of buzzwords — job-hopping, job hugging, quiet quitting — and the looming, yet still undefined, shadow of AI’s impact on the workforce. But amid the noise, one statistic from a recent large-scale study demands […]
When the Big Boss Behaves Badly: 3 Things HR Wants to Do in Wake of Nvidia Scandal
What happens when the big boss behaves badly? It’s a question HR pros are asking in the wake of the Nvidia scandal: The CEO, Jensen Huang, had admitted to one extramarital affair and another is alleged. One of the mistresses is accused of being a Chinese spy, possibly compromising national security. The other is alleged […]
10 Tips to Improve Employee Engagement as Engagement Rates Plummet
HR professionals might consider employee engagement the glue that holds company success together. No matter what you talk about – productivity, leadership, professional growth, retention, recognition, culture, well-being – everything ties back to employee engagement. Not to mention, it is the most important indicator to gauge work satisfaction. But it’s at high risk: Employee engagement […]
Help Employees Customize Their Career Paths | 2-Minute Video
Most employees don’t want to follow the traditional career path these days. Some have a background or experience in one field and get interested in another. Others might see better opportunities outside their current chosen path. So if you want to keep good employees, you’ll also want to help them build a career path that […]
3 Ways to Turn Succession Planning into a Companywide Talent Strategy
Have you named who will fill that role when your tenured leader retires? Will you keep the position limited to one person or will you divide it and create additional roles? Which roles will be backfilled as you move people up? With succession planning in mind, these questions should be top of mind for HR […]
Slowmaxxing: What It Is and Why HR Needs to Be Concerned
Slowmaxxing has hit the workplace. It’s the latest in the world of “maxxing” — when people take an activity to the extreme to get major benefits. Slowmaxxing started as a wellness trend centered on mindfulness and slowing down everyday routines. And according to experts at Owl Labs, it has spilled into the workplace, with employees […]