Open Enrollment: 5 Things Employees Most Often Misunderstand
By

When you’re an HR pro, open enrollment season means your inbox and voicemail will be full of questions. Employees will be knocking on your door to get their questions answered. Others will stop you in the hall to ask more.
Employees are confused before it even starts. And they need your help.
The best way to help: Know what employees most often misunderstand about open enrollment and address those with good information early in the process.
Most HR pros work with their brokers on a presentation that reflects all the work they recently did – assessing current benefits, examining costs and doing surveys to gauge the impact of the benefits. You bundle it up into a nice, neat benefits guide and a presentation on the details of the open enrollment process.
But what’s often missing are simple explanations of what employees misunderstand most.
How to Explain Open Enrollment to Employees
Here are the top five things most people – sometimes even HR people – have a difficult time understanding during open enrollment, plus tips on helping them make sense of it.
1. Privacy Standards
For more than five years, employers have been encouraged to do more for their employees’ mental health, overall well-being and work/life balance. But many employers don’t ensure that the use of these benefits is private.
Remember, it’s illegal for employers to see who used Employee Assistance Program (EAP) services. EAP vendors have strict regulations. Employers can know how many people used an EAP site, hotline or program, but not who they were, where they were or what role they have in the company.
Some employees believe employer-provided coverage allows them to know all about their medical usage.
You want to define the privacy standard in plain English for leaders and employees. Avoid using the blanket HIPAA statement, which can be confusing and off-putting.
2. HRA, HSA, FSA Differences
While Health Reimbursement Arrangements (HRA), Health Savings Accounts (HSA) and Flexible Spending Accounts (FSA) provide ways for reimbursement of medical costs, they all have differences that employees often can’t distinguish.
Some roll over from year to year. Others need employees to enroll in them every year. Some can’t be combined. And others have usage restrictions.
During open enrollment, plainly define the essential parameters of each account, the overlap and how being in each plan can benefit the employee. This is a perfect place for grid graphs for employees to compare the elements you offer.
3. In-Network Providers vs. Out-of-Network Providers
Whether you’re fully insured or self-insured, people often have issues finding in-network providers.
For instance, if a benefits survey uncovers a disconnect where some people rate the dental coverage the best and others rate it the worst, it could be that the people who gave it poor ratings are using out-of-network providers and aren’t aware of it.
Help employees recognize that the best way for a member to verify an in-network provider is to register online with your provider directly. Show them exactly how, once they’re logged in via an app or the Internet, they can see coverage, claims and providers, and print ID cards.
This is important because many companies that have plans administered by another party may use a separate provider network, which may cause confusion with provider verification. Many providers have also moved away from mailing IDs for dental, vision and other benefits.
4. How to Get Help With Claims
During open enrollment, employees make elections weeks or months before the new coverage takes effect — but it’s often much longer until they use those newly elected benefits.
One way to fix the disconnect is to ensure your self-service platform displays the current elections each employee has. Another low-tech option is to create a wallet card with names of providers, phone numbers and websites.
Send out quarterly reminders of the plans you offer and how to obtain help with claims or log in to the carrier websites as a member to reduce confusion and increase employee satisfaction.
HR’s Compliance Toolkit: Stay Ahead of Changing Federal and State Regulations
5. Differences in Disability Benefits
I once discovered during an open enrollment prep that five people were signed up for long-term disability (LTD) when they would’ve been better signed up for short-term disability (STD).
Why? No one had made it clear that STD covered the first few months of a qualifying leave and LTD started after the STD ended, roughly after three months of being unpaid.
While disability benefits aren’t usually at the top of the topics during open enrollment, they need to be part of the conversation. Clearly define the differences and invite employees who want more information to ask questions later in a more private setting.
Be Ready to Answer Unasked Questions
Benefits misconceptions exist in every organization, and not every employee will ask enough questions. All plans differ in terms and change even during renewal periods. Even if you’ve explained things previously and haven’t had turnover or plan changes, repetition helps.
It’s the responsibility of the HR benefits administration team to successfully communicate the value of employee benefits. Make sure to explain your benefits clearly and simply each year. Concise but detailed summaries are an important part of a benefits guide. The more your employees understand and value your benefits, the greater the employee satisfaction rating will be.
Further Reading
IRS Raises 2027 Retirement Contribution Limits for 401(k)
The IRS has announced that the 2027 contribution limit for 401(k), 403(b) and 457(b) retirement plans will increase to $25,500, up from $24,500 in 2026. Higher Catch-Up Limits Boost Retirement Savings Catch-up limits are going up, too: The higher catch-up replaces the standard one, so employees can’t stack the two. And employees can make catch-up […]
Paid Parental Leave: New Requirements for Allegheny County Employers
On Oct. 22, 2026, Allegheny County, Pa., enacted what’s believed to be the nation’s first countywide paid parental leave mandate. Employers must comply by October 2027. Employers doing business in the county with 15 or more employees anywhere must fund 12 weeks at base pay, capped at $4,200 weekly, for birth, adoption, child placement or […]
Washington Paid Leave Premium Increases Jan. 1
On Jan. 1, 2027, Washington’s Paid Family & Medical Leave premium increases to 1.2%, from 1.13%. Employers will pay 29.3% of the paid leave premium; the employee share is 70.7%. Employers may cover some or all of employees’ share. Generally, employers with fewer than 50 employees don’t need to pay the employer share unless they […]
Year-End Fringe Benefits: Check Payroll’s Accounting Cutoff
With year-end approaching, payroll teams should review whether the IRS’s optional special accounting rule makes sense for certain taxable noncash fringe benefits. The rule lets employers treat benefits provided during November and December (or a shorter period within those months) as paid in the following year. For example, personal use of a company vehicle in […]
Handy Open Enrollment Jargon Cheat Sheet for You
Open enrollment can be a hectic time of year for HR pros and the employees you help. Add open enrollment jargon to the mix, and you can ensure confusion will flourish. Clarifying Open Enrollment Jargon So we’re equipping our readers — and your employees — with a handy jargon cheat sheet to get through benefits […]
Massachusetts Changes PFML Contribution Allocation for 2027
Massachusetts recently updated its paid family and medical leave contribution guidance after passing Chapter 101 of the Acts of 2026. The changes take effect Jan. 1, 2027. The law shifts employer contributions from medical leave to family leave to mitigate the impact of IRS guidance on PFML benefit taxation. Employers with 25 or more covered […]