IC-Turned-W-2 Employee Sues for OT Pay: Why Court Backed Employer
By

A former employee who sometimes worked 18-hour days couldn’t convince the Sixth Circuit he was entitled to overtime pay. Here’s why the court backed the employer.
From Offer Letter to Overtime Lawsuit
After working with Cincinnati Bell for several years through an outside vendor, Loren Bennink joined the company as a W-2 employee in May 2016. His employment offer letter listed pay of $75 an hour and placed him in a job class the company treated as exempt under the Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA). The letter stated it wasn’t a contract.
Cincinnati Bell paid Bennink $3,000 a week, the equivalent of $75 per hour for 40 hours, regardless of hours worked. Over time, Bennink said his workload became too much for one person, sometimes requiring 18-hour workdays. He left the company and sued for overtime for hours worked over 40 in a workweek. The case reached the Sixth Circuit.
White Papers
Building an Adoption-Friendly Workplace: Benefits That Help Families Grow and Employees Stay
Exempt or Nonexempt? A Closer Look at the Computer Employee Exemption
Under the FLSA, the computer employee exemption has pay and duties requirements. A qualifying computer employee must earn at least $684 a week on a salary basis, or $27.63 an hour if paid hourly.
The parties disputed whether Bennink was paid hourly or salaried but agreed his pay exceeded the hourly threshold. For that reason, the Sixth Circuit focused on his job duties.
For the exemption to apply, Cincinnati Bell had to show that Bennink’s main responsibility involved work such as designing, developing or documenting computer systems or programs to meet user needs or technical specifications.
Bennink argued the phone system wasn’t a computer system and his documentation was just flowcharts. He also cited his lack of formal computer training and reliance on others for programming.
But the court wasn’t swayed, pointing out that the interactive voice response system was a computer system. Bennink helped design, develop and document it by mapping call flows and determining how it should meet user needs, it reasoned.
His project-management work and reliance on others for programming didn’t change that conclusion. Nor did his lack of formal training: the exemption requires no particular degree, education or job title, the court noted.
The Sixth Circuit affirmed summary judgment for Cincinnati Bell, finding Bennink qualified for the exemption and wasn’t entitled to overtime pay. It also rejected a contract claim, finding the $75 hourly rate in Bennink’s offer letter didn’t establish an agreement to pay him for every hour worked.
More info: Bennink v. Cincinnati Bell Telephone Co.
Further Reading
Colorado Cuts FAMLI Premium Rate to 0.86% for 2027
Colorado’s Family and Medical Leave Insurance (FAMLI) premium rate will decrease from 0.88% to 0.86% of wages effective Jan. 1, 2027. The new rate applies to all employers using the state plan. Employers should update payroll settings before their first 2027 pay run, according to the state’s FAMLI Business Brief. Employees may pay no more […]
2027 IRS Limits Are Out: Here’s What Payroll Should Handle First
The 2027 IRS limits are out. In Rev. Proc. 2026-35, the IRS announced inflation adjustments covering almost 70 tax provisions. But you don’t need to tackle them all at once. Start with the benefit elections employees are making right now. Health Accounts Take Priority Open enrollment is underway at many companies, so health accounts are […]
IRS Raises 2027 Retirement Contribution Limits for 401(k)
The IRS has announced that the 2027 contribution limit for 401(k), 403(b) and 457(b) retirement plans will increase to $25,500, up from $24,500 in 2026. Higher Catch-Up Limits Boost Retirement Savings Catch-up limits are going up, too: The higher catch-up replaces the standard one, so employees can’t stack the two. And employees can make catch-up […]
W-2 Fraud Lawsuit Over Cash Wages Moves Forward
Most payroll pros would rather not start thinking about W-2s until after Thanksgiving. But a new ruling on unreported cash wages should be on your radar now. Do Unreported Cash Wages Amount to W-2 Fraud? Eight former employees at a Hempstead, N.Y., car wash sued its operators, alleging the employer paid some wages off the […]
Oklahoma Unemployment Tax Rates & Wage Base Drop Jan. 1
On Jan. 1, 2027, Oklahoma’s unemployment insurance taxable wage base decreases to $24,400 per employee, down from $25,000. Tax rates for experienced employers will range from 0.1% to 5.5%, down from 0.2% to 5.8% in 2026. The new-employer rate remains 1.5%. The Oklahoma Employment Security Commission uses each employer’s benefit wage ratio and the state’s […]
New York Expands Pay Protections for Construction Workers, Effective Dec. 8
Covered construction employers in New York face reporting-pay and shift-cancellation pay obligations under the state’s Construction Reporting Pay Act. As of Dec. 8, 2026, covered employees who report for work at their employer’s request or with its permission must receive at least four hours’ pay, or their regularly scheduled shift if shorter, at their promised […]