Conquer the Worst Parts of Small Business HR: Benefits and Taxes
By

The biggest pain points of small business HR are employee benefits and payroll tax filing, according to a survey by HR software company Justworks and Harris Poll.
Julia D’Amico, the VP of benefits at Justworks, commented in an interview that the most common reason why payroll taxes become a stumbling block for small business HR pros is manual processing errors — which are sometimes followed by a scary letter from a government agency like the IRS.
Seventy-one percent of the survey respondents agreed that business tax rules are too complicated and confusing for most people to understand.
“When you’re doing things that are related to compliance with state and local authorities, if you make one mistake then the process by which an HR professional has to fix it is not clear and it’s not straightforward,” she said.
White Papers
Building an Adoption-Friendly Workplace: Benefits That Help Families Grow and Employees Stay
D’Amico noted that a lot of her company’s customers are small business owners who opted to outsource tax expertise because they’re too busy to keep track of important year-over-year legislative changes that directly affect them, such as tax law and the dozens of state paid family leave laws.
“Technology is … a great way to make sure that those state and local regulations — and then all of the rules that carriers impose upon benefits — are [followed] and … you don’t have to be an expert on them,” she said.
Benefits Administration Help for Small Business HR
Among the small business owners who participated in the survey, 67% said managing health benefits was more difficult than they thought it was going to be when they first went into business. For instance, they may not have anticipated navigating compliance with Employee Retirement Income Security Act of 1974 rules that regulate health plan transparency and accountability.
“The way that technology solutions like Justworks can help [is by] putting guardrails [in place for small business HR] that make it so that those laws are codified in the software and that … the employer’s … [not] hoping the math aligns with the law,” D’Amico said.
She added that keeping the software in sync with the law involves behind-the-scenes collaboration between experts in the field and the software company’s legal, public affairs and tech teams. Best-in-class tech vendors will proactively reach out to their small business HR customers when a regulatory change is coming and say something like, “Hey, you might read something unexpected in the news. Don’t worry, we have you covered. Here’s what it means, here’s what you have to do and here’s where we already took care of it.”
Technology solutions on the market can also help small business HR pros design and administer a competitive benefits program.
“By using … simple and intuitively-built technology to explain to an HR professional … this is what they’re really signing up for and this is what is available to them. They’re able to decide … this is the right set of plans while still taking care of their teams,” she said.
“And so it’s really about simplifying all of the confusing terminology, like co-pays and deductibles, so they can make a decision with confidence, and that they can know that the decision that they made both takes care of their team and is compliant with [Affordable Care Act] law.”
Best-in-class platforms will be backed by a team of humans that:
- curates what D’Amico called “the right sets of partnerships” related to employee benefits
- makes the details available to small business HR leaders, and
- negotiates a competitive rate with benefits carriers — maybe even a special rate that was previously unavailable to small businesses.
Advice for Businesses Afraid to Commit
Small business HR might not have the budgetary resources to invest in technology that can solve the pain points of tax compliance and benefits management.
D’Amico had these words of encouragement for making a business case for a tech investment: “Instead of focusing on the cost of the software, think about all of the hours [the software] will give [you] back that can be put toward growing [your] business.”
BetterBuys.com has valuable info on payroll and HRMS system vendors that can help, and don’t miss the HRMorning webinar “HR Tech for Small Businesses: Ditch the Paper Chase for Good” on July 18.
Further Reading
Is Employee Monitoring Software Worth the Security Risks?
Many HR departments rely on employee monitoring software, sometimes called bossware, to track how remote teams spend their time. However, this monitoring often requires storing screenshots, keystrokes and messages in systems that can become attractive targets for attackers. 6 Key Risks Tied to Employee Monitoring Software Before relying on such bossware, HR teams benefit from […]
Which HR Tasks Should Never Be Fully Replaced by AI?
AI is now a bigger part of everyday operations, including taking over some HR tasks. Automating resume screening, scheduling interviews, workforce analytics, and performance reporting genuinely frees HR teams to spend more time where it matters most. For organizations trying to move faster and operate more efficiently, these tools have real value. But there is […]
Connecticut Joins States Regulating Workplace AI: 7 Compliance Steps
Connecticut is putting employers on notice over workplace AI. Effective Oct. 1, 2026, SB 5 clarifies that Connecticut employers facing a discrimination claim can’t blame the artificial intelligence (AI) tools they use to make hiring, promotion, discipline or termination decisions. Other changes that kicked in the same day: And there’s more coming. The law’s second […]
AI Helps and Hinders, but Employees Can Get the Most Out of It With These 6 Skills
AI helps employees do their jobs: On average, they spend an hour and a half each day using AI. But it’s not all good productivity: Employees spend about half an hour of that time troubleshooting AI errors and on prompt iteration, according to BambooHR’s report, Redesigning Work: AI’s Performance Review. This hasn’t stopped employees’ enthusiasm […]
California’s New Workplace AI Laws: 8 Takeaways for HR
California is again the testing ground for workplace technology rules. On Sept. 30, 2026, Gov. Gavin Newsom signed a group of laws that limit how employers use artificial intelligence (AI) to monitor, evaluate and lay off workers. Together, they reach discipline, surveillance and reductions in force, three areas where HR decisions increasingly run through software. […]
3 Ways HR Can Co-Author Your AI Strategy, Not Just React to It
Most organizations approach their AI strategy the same way they approach every major technology rollout: They build the system, train the users and measure adoption before finally moving on. But AI is fundamentally different. It changes how work gets done, how teams make decisions, and shifts what skills matter most for long-term success. That requires […]