Something’s Wrong With Hiring, and It’s Not AI: 2 Reasons Buried in the Data
By

Many employers claim they’ve cut back on hiring because AI can do the job entry-level work employees once did.
But a new report from BambooHR tells a different story.
BambooHR looked at five years of data from more than 72 million job applications and 6.5 million completed hires — and the results ran counter to the narrative that AI is to blame for the slowdown. And they aren’t convinced we’re on an uptick. Yet.
Different Perspective on Hiring Stats
Some of the most telling Bamboo stats include:
- Applicants per job posting have nearly doubled: In 2021, it was about 45, and is 95 in 2025. But completed hires have fallen every year since 2022, dropping more than 20% — from 1.34M to 1.05M.
- The hiring rate fell. It dropped from 4.5% to 2.8% over the same period, even as job postings held steady.
- Companies promoted from within during the Great Stability. Internal mobility now accounts for 62% of all role fills, up from 51% in 2021, as companies grow more cautious about external hires.
- On the surface, AI looks big, but … AI-related job titles grew by 218% since 2021, but 83% of those roles were in tech, and even within tech, they represent just 1.5% of all titles. AI is reshaping demand, but not broadly and not evenly.
- Remote is falling out of style. Remote mentions in job postings fell more than 60% since their 2022 peak — from 4.2% to 1.6%.
“Many employers still assume hiring is hard because the market is tight or candidates are unwilling to move,” said Brandon Welch, Senior Director of Talent Acquisition at BambooHR. “But in many cases, the real issue is that organizations are asking the funnel to do too much. When organizational uncertainty exists, decision-making is slow, or screening signals become noisy, candidate volume then stops being an advantage and starts becoming friction.”
Why Employers Struggle to Hire Right
If you’ve struggled to hire right — or want to ensure you get it right if you’re about rev up hiring again after the hiatus that’s been going on — you’ll want to know what BambooHR researchers found: two dynamics that quietly compounded hiring problems in many organizations.
- Workload creep: This is the gradual, often unnoticed expansion of employee responsibilities beyond their original job description, without a corresponding increase in pay, title, or resources. When workload creep goes unaddressed, it distorts hiring. Organizations post roles to solve problems that are actually symptoms of overburdened teams, not genuine headcount gaps.
- Critical role drift: This happens when the fundamental requirements of a position essential to the company’s competitive advantage shift over time without formal updates to the job design. The result is a mismatch between what the role was built to do and what the work actually demands.
“Both dynamics inflate hiring activity without producing desired hiring outcomes,” the researchers said.
The hiring reboot starts with role reviews.
Further Reading
70+ U.S. Companies Affected by Remote Worker Fraud: FBI Issues New Guidance
You’ve reviewed an applicant’s resume and conducted an interview. But how can you be sure the remote worker you’re planning to bring onto your payroll is who they claim to be? More hiring managers are finding out that a candidate who looks great on paper and interviews well may still be an impostor. In a […]
How Military Veterans Can Improve Hiring and Retention
As our nation celebrates Veterans’ Day, consider increasing your efforts to find, recruit and retain veterans to your organization. Try it now as a catalyst to hire and retain more veterans for years to come. The voluntary quit rate is about 2%, according to data from the Labor Department. But if companies continue to hire […]
Connecticut Joins States Regulating Workplace AI: 7 Compliance Steps
Connecticut is putting employers on notice over workplace AI. Effective Oct. 1, 2026, SB 5 clarifies that Connecticut employers facing a discrimination claim can’t blame the artificial intelligence (AI) tools they use to make hiring, promotion, discipline or termination decisions. Other changes that kicked in the same day: And there’s more coming. The law’s second […]
Sirius XM Wins Dismissal of AI Hiring Bias Lawsuit
An applicant who alleged Sirius XM’s hiring software repeatedly screened him out because he’s Black recently had his complaint dismissed – for now. A federal judge in Michigan dismissed the complaint without prejudice on Sept. 30, 2026, finding that the applicant hadn’t alleged enough facts to state a plausible discrimination claim. Applicant Alleges AI Hiring […]
12 HR Horror Stories That Will Make You Laugh Out Loud
In HR, it’s rainbows, cupcakes and smiley emojis most of the time, right? Except for the HR horror stories. And we have some doozies here for you! HR pros have tales from the dark side of recruiting, retaining and listening to employees vent. And they’re often a big part of the reason HR pros are […]
Posting Ghost Jobs Could Be Illegal: 7 Better Ways to Recruit
Lawmakers in several states have proposed bills targeting Ghost Jobs – roles posted that don’t exist or employers don’t intend to fill immediately. One state attorney general is investigating the legality of posting Ghost Jobs and profiting from it. The numbers speak some truth behind lawmakers’ concerns. About 25% of employers that have an open […]