Supreme Court Deals New Blow to Agency Power, Kills 40-Year-Old Rule
By

A new U.S. Supreme Court washes away a 40-year-old rule that gave federal agencies broad power to fill in the blanks when federal laws are ambiguous.
As a result, courts now have a greater say when it comes to deciding what ambiguous statutory language means and how the law is to be applied. The ruling essentially transfers a significant degree of power away from agencies and to court tribunals.
The decision follows closely on the heels on another recent Supreme Court ruling that curtailed the power of the National Labor Relations Board to gain early injunctions for employees in cases involving labor disputes.
The Supreme Court’s ruling in the new case placed its earlier decision in Chevron U.S.A. Inc. v. Natural Resources Defense Council, Inc., 467 U.S. 837 (1984) under the microscope. In Chevron, the Court set a rule that said if statutory language is ambiguous, courts are to defer to agency interpretations of the law as long as those interpretations are reasonable.
Because it is not uncommon to find ambiguity in federal statutes, in practice the rule gave federal agencies significant power to say what the law is.
Rule Was Applied Over and Over
What became known as Chevron deference has been granted in thousands of cases since the rule was established, including cases involving employment law issues.
The new Supreme Court ruling explicitly overrules the landmark Chevron decision, saying that courts must exercise their own independent judgment when deciding whether a federal agency has properly interpreted a statute – and that courts should not defer to an agency’s interpretation just because the statute at issue is ambiguous.
The issue of Chevron’s continuing viability reached the Supreme Court in the form of a challenge to a National Marine Fisheries Service (NMFS) rule that required certain fishermen to bear costs associated with onboard observers who were tasked with collecting data in connection with conservation and management efforts. The observers could cost up to about $700 a day and significantly reduce the vessel owner’s returns.
Fishermen Challenge Agency Rule
Atlantic herring fishing businesses challenged the rule, saying the NMFS lacked the authority to require them to make the payments. The relevant statute, called the Magnuson-Stevens Fishery Conservation and Management Act (MSA), does not include specific terms that address whether Atlantic herring fishermen may be forced to pay costs associated with observers.
A federal appeals court applied Chevron and ruled for the government. More specifically, it decided that the agency’s decision to require payment was a reasonable construction of the MSA.
A separate group raised an unsuccessful similar challenge in a different suit, and the Supreme Court agreed to accept both cases for further review.
By a 6-3 vote, the Court struck down the Chevron rule, ushering in a new era of increased court power to give definitive meaning to unclear statutory language.
Who Holds the Power — and How Much?
As early as 1803, the decision noted, the Supreme Court has made it clear that it is “the province and duty of the judicial department to say what the law is.” Translation: Courts should get the last word.
At the same time, it said, it has also been long established that courts should give “due respect” to executive branch interpretations of federal statutes. Despite this principle, however, courts still must independently interpret the statute at issue, the majority decision said.
It is the job of courts to decide all relevant questions of law, the Court said.
“[A]gencies have no special competence in resolving statutory ambiguities,” the majority ruling asserts. “Courts do.”
The rulings below were vacated, and the cases were remanded.
What New Supreme Court Ruling Means for HR
This ruling will make it easier for claimants to challenge federal agency interpretations of federal statutes.
In the employment context, it will affect regulatory oversight and enforcement efforts of the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission, the Department of Labor, the Occupational Health and Safety Administration, and the National Labor Relations Board.
HR administrators may now rely less heavily on agency guidance that is intended to clarify ambiguous statutory language. Unfortunately, this means there will be less certainty and predictability for those seeking agency guidance from those sources on cloudy HR-related issues. The proverbial grain of salt now is at play with respect to a large swath of federal agency guidance.
Loper Bright Enterprises v. Raimondo, No. 22-451 (U.S. 6/28/24).
Further Reading
FMLA Intermittent Leave: 8 Questions HR Asks Most
Partial days, doctor’s notes, late arrivals. If intermittent FMLA leave keeps you guessing, these eight answers can help clear things up for HR.
Unpaid Pre-Shift Work Costs New Jersey Employer $725K
A New Jersey drywall installer must pay $725,000 after failing to pay 48 workers overtime for pre-shift work performed while they waited for transportation to job sites. The U.S. Department of Labor’s (DOL) Wage and Hour Division found P & B Partitions Inc. violated the Fair Labor Standards Act’s overtime rules. The company also refused […]
Connecticut Joins States Regulating Workplace AI: 7 Compliance Steps
Connecticut is putting employers on notice over workplace AI. Effective Oct. 1, 2026, SB 5 clarifies that Connecticut employers facing a discrimination claim can’t blame the artificial intelligence (AI) tools they use to make hiring, promotion, discipline or termination decisions. Other changes that kicked in the same day: And there’s more coming. The law’s second […]
USCIS Plans to Abolish 60-Day Grace Period for Certain Nonimmigrant Workers
On Sept. 11, the U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS) published a Notice of Proposed Rulemaking that, if adopted, would eliminate the 60-day grace period currently granted to most nonimmigrant workers in H-1B, H-1B1, E-1, E-2, E-3, L-1, O-1 or TN status who abruptly lose their positions. The grace period has been in place since […]
Pa. Court Sets 3-Year Deadline for Minimum Wage Act Claims
Pennsylvania employers face a three-year window for employees to sue over unpaid minimum wages or overtime under state law, rather than the six years a trial court previously allowed. The ruling came in a case involving 20 pharmacy employees seeking overtime for work done from 2017 to 2019. The employers argued the claims were filed […]
Hidden Payroll Rounding Risk: Unpaid Pre-Shift Time Under Scrutiny
Required pre-shift tasks – and whether employees are paid for them – are at the center of a former hospital nurse’s wage dispute. Chestnut Hill Hospital required nurses to change into surgical scrubs by 7 a.m. for a morning huddle. Pamela McBride sued under the Fair Labor Standards Act, alleging the hospital didn’t pay her […]