How to disagree with your boss – and still have a good relationship
By

Your boss has a really good idea — at least she thinks so — and you hate it. Awkward, isn’t it?
But how do you disagree with your boss?
On one hand, you owe it to your company to point out the problems. On the other hand, you don’t want to hurt a good relationship.
Fortunately, you can disagree with the boss — or anyone — when necessary and still maintain the relationship. Even better, you can accomplish goals.
A disagreement worth having?
“Now is the perfect moment to focus on the skills we need to navigate the often tricky terrain of getting along with others,” says Amy Gallo, in her book Getting Along.
In most instances, it’s important to respectfully disagree with your boss (or colleague) when a greater good can be accomplished — perhaps your point of view can improve quality, creativity or revenue. Or perhaps your point of view is incorrect, and there’s something for you to learn.
Gallo, who is also the cohost of HBR’s Women at Work podcast, offers these six proven strategies to disagree with your boss (or colleague or friend) and maintain a great relationship.
1. Think about it
Don’t just blurt out your point of view. It may seem timely to say it right now. But a well-thought opinion is almost always a better argument than a timely one.
Be strategic. Think it through by asking yourself:
- Why do I disagree?
- Could the disagreement be perceived as “political?”
- Do I have the good of the organization (project, group) at heart of the disagreement?
Ideally, you don’t have any personal gain from winning the argument.
2. Get it right
Follow this rule I was taught decades ago when I was crime reporter for a wire service: Get it first. But get it right first.
In other words, get your facts straight before you broach the subject. And recognize that your boss may have access to more information than you do.
If you even suspect you’re missing something, couch your argument by saying something like, “I think there’s another way to look at this. Before I present my ideas, can you tell me of any other critical facts I don’t know?”
3. Test your idea
Bounce your point of view — including the facts you know — off a few trusted colleagues. If you can’t convince them it’s a better idea, you probably won’t be able to convince your boss.
So get feedback on your idea and on ways to be more persuasive. Encourage them to poke holes in your theory and ask questions they think any executive would have.
And don’t ask your direct reports to chime in. They may not want to disagree with you and likely won’t give the candid feedback you need.
4. Offer an expert
Get a respected, credible expert to go over your conclusions before you take your idea to the boss. Then offer to have him or her review it with your boss after you present it.
It doesn’t have to be an outside consultant. It should be a person recognized within your company or among your mutual network as an expert on the topic.
5. Prepare
Pull together data, charts, spreadsheets and any other hard evidence you can to support your point of view. Leave out hypotheticals and anecdotes.
Disagreeing with a boss is time for a businesslike approach.
6. Call on a buddy
People trust their friends, particularly those who are at the same level as them.
Find someone who is your boss’ friend and at the same level as your boss, and use your data to convince him or her of the merit behind your idea. Ask him or her to back your idea.
That’s not to suggest you gang up on your boss. You just want to find genuine support from someone who can address it in a friendly manner, too.
Further Reading
70+ U.S. Companies Affected by Remote Worker Fraud: FBI Issues New Guidance
You’ve reviewed an applicant’s resume and conducted an interview. But how can you be sure the remote worker you’re planning to bring onto your payroll is who they claim to be? More hiring managers are finding out that a candidate who looks great on paper and interviews well may still be an impostor. In a […]
Post-Election Fallout: 2 Ways to Manage New Tension in the Workplace
With the midterms over, you’d probably like to put the occasional (or frequent?) contentious moments any election can cause behind you. But it’s not likely to end with the last vote cast. HR and other leaders often face a recurring challenge in post-election times: acknowledging and managing politically charged moments that can turn up tension […]
An ‘Insecurity Tax’ Could Hurt Retention: 4 Solutions to Keep Your Talent
The last decade of corporate churn might have revealed this surprising lesson: One of the biggest threats to retention isn’t compensation, remote work or even AI. It could be managerial insecurity. When leadership is rooted in a manager’s personal anxiety, organizational behavior becomes entirely predictable. Micromanagement, hoarding authority, avoiding constructive dissent, and making defensive decisions […]
Politics at Work: An Election-Season Toolkit for HR Leaders
Employers everywhere are bracing for one of the trickiest challenges of the year as the country goes through another contentious election season. Inflammatory political speech in the workplace is disruptive and can lead to a host of workplace issues ranging from frustration and fractured relationships to claims of harassment and workplace violence incidents. With increasing […]
Are You Keeping Workforce Data Longer Than You Need To?
When an employee leaves, HR closes the personnel file, processes the final paycheck, and shuts off system access. Copies of that employee’s information can remain in places HR does not manage: email archives, collaboration platforms, badge-access logs, fleet telematics systems, and the files of recruiting, payroll and benefits vendors. Some of those records have to […]
How Managers Are the Missing Link in Workforce Capability: 3 Solutions
Managers are the bridge between business strategy, day-to-day execution, and organizational growth. Understanding and developing workforce capability has always been central to that role. And for HR leaders, a manager’s ability to do that well impacts everything from internal mobility and succession planning to retention and workforce readiness. The challenge is that workforce capability is […]