Too much of a good thing: 5 leadership traits to reel in
By

Could anyone ever be so good at managing employees that they get bad at it?
Absolutely.
And it most often happens when they take some leadership traits to the extreme.
“When it comes to leadership, is there such a thing as too much of a good thing? There sure can be. In fact, just about any weakness can be attributed to one or more strengths that are overused,” says Dan McCarthy, Owner of Great Leadership and its blog and author of The Great Leadership Development and Succession Planning eBook.
There are times when a leadership strength can turn into a weakness – and undermine your effectiveness.
Leadership traits: Dial up or down?
Taking a strength to an extreme is always detrimental to performance, Harvard Business Review researchers found. More interesting — or perhaps troubling — is that even a mild tendency to overdo it can be harmful.
Still, managers face a lot of different situations and need to know when to turn up and down a leadership strength.
So when you manage people and processes, you want to use strengths strategically and not overload. A perfect balance is an imperfect art.
Here are five of the top leadership traits, where there’s some danger in using them too much – and how to avoid an overdose.
Courage
Managers need to make plenty of tough decisions. That’s where they learn to stand up for what’s right even when it goes against the grain.
But misguided courage can turn a good manager into one who’s uncompromising and overly critical, burning people and bridges along the way.
To avoid it: Take a pulse check at two important junctures – when facing tough decisions and when no one seems to agree with you. A trusted mentor can help you recognize if your level of courage is within reasonable boundaries or has exploded into a sense of omnipotence.
Compassion
Managers need to care about their employees, company and results. But too much concern can cloud judgment on tough, personal issues, such as under-performance.
Compassion can be seen as naiveté, and an overly nice manager can be taken advantage of.
To avoid this: It’s important to be friendly and caring with employees, but don’t be a pushover. Base all decisions on documented performance and experience.
Enabling
Giving employees training, assignments and freedom to do their work are important tools to empower them in their roles.
Giving them too much room by over-delegating or employing a complete hands-off management style can set up employees (and you) for failure. Not to mention, managers who give up too much power can be seen as shirking their responsibilities.
To avoid this: Delegate and assign work with expectations of how and when progress will be reported. Let employees help decide when they’re ready to take on more responsibility, but you make the final decision based on past ability to achieve goals.
Focus
The C-suite loves a focused manager who gets things done and delivers better-than-expected results.
The problem arises when managers are so focused that they get results at the expense of good people, time and resources.
To avoid this: Shoot for goals, while considering the consequences of decisions along the way. Ask yourself often, “Who and what will be impacted by this decision?”
Brilliance
Brilliant managers are often one step ahead of everyone and can successfully strategize simple and complex things.
The problem: They disregard others’ views and are unreasonably impatient. The result is poor relationships.
To avoid this: Never assume you can do it alone. Even when you’re convinced you’re right, enlist another manager to review your work or decisions.
“The lesson here is when strengths are overdone, they can turn into weaknesses,” McCarthy says. “While it’s good to be aware of and leverage your strengths, don’t overuse your strengths to the point where they can have negative side effects. Be open to feedback and learn to ‘dial it back,’ especially when under pressure.”
Further Reading
70+ U.S. Companies Affected by Remote Worker Fraud: FBI Issues New Guidance
You’ve reviewed an applicant’s resume and conducted an interview. But how can you be sure the remote worker you’re planning to bring onto your payroll is who they claim to be? More hiring managers are finding out that a candidate who looks great on paper and interviews well may still be an impostor. In a […]
Post-Election Fallout: 2 Ways to Manage New Tension in the Workplace
With the midterms over, you’d probably like to put the occasional (or frequent?) contentious moments any election can cause behind you. But it’s not likely to end with the last vote cast. HR and other leaders often face a recurring challenge in post-election times: acknowledging and managing politically charged moments that can turn up tension […]
An ‘Insecurity Tax’ Could Hurt Retention: 4 Solutions to Keep Your Talent
The last decade of corporate churn might have revealed this surprising lesson: One of the biggest threats to retention isn’t compensation, remote work or even AI. It could be managerial insecurity. When leadership is rooted in a manager’s personal anxiety, organizational behavior becomes entirely predictable. Micromanagement, hoarding authority, avoiding constructive dissent, and making defensive decisions […]
Politics at Work: An Election-Season Toolkit for HR Leaders
Employers everywhere are bracing for one of the trickiest challenges of the year as the country goes through another contentious election season. Inflammatory political speech in the workplace is disruptive and can lead to a host of workplace issues ranging from frustration and fractured relationships to claims of harassment and workplace violence incidents. With increasing […]
Are You Keeping Workforce Data Longer Than You Need To?
When an employee leaves, HR closes the personnel file, processes the final paycheck, and shuts off system access. Copies of that employee’s information can remain in places HR does not manage: email archives, collaboration platforms, badge-access logs, fleet telematics systems, and the files of recruiting, payroll and benefits vendors. Some of those records have to […]
How Managers Are the Missing Link in Workforce Capability: 3 Solutions
Managers are the bridge between business strategy, day-to-day execution, and organizational growth. Understanding and developing workforce capability has always been central to that role. And for HR leaders, a manager’s ability to do that well impacts everything from internal mobility and succession planning to retention and workforce readiness. The challenge is that workforce capability is […]