Skip to main content

Lessons From a Company That Told Employees What NOT to Say

MM

By

Last updated February 24, 20252 min read
Lessons From a Company That Told Employees What NOT to Say

Would you ever tell your employee what not to say? 

One company put limits on what employees could talk about in the workplace, essentially banning many sensitive topics.

It led to praise, outcry, resignations and lots of banter outside the company.

What Happened When Told What Not to Say

Software company Basecamp CEO Jason Fried wrote in a company blog post: “No more societal and political discussions … ”

He said those types of conversations are “a major distraction. It saps our energy, and redirects our dialog toward dark places.”

But he didn’t deny employees opportunities to express their opinions completely.

Fried also encouraged employees to “continue these difficult discussions with willing colleagues on other systems,” and “exercise your right to activism and political engagement outside of work.”

What to Ask Ourselves

Some people loved it. Some hated it.

Either way, it presents communication questions for HR leaders everywhere:

  • Can you ban what employees talk about?
  • Is there a practical way to keep communication civil?

Yes, you can ban conversations about certain subjects. But you can’t expect that discussions won’t happen.

Employees are human, and they talk about things that matter to them. Conversation is one way they engage. They may not intentionally pursue sensitive subjects, but one comment leads to another.

For instance, and as one Basecamp employee questioned: What happens if I bring up my kids’ school and it leads to a chat about the elected school board? Is that then a political conversation?

Encourage Better Conversations

Generally, leaders have to be careful about limiting what employees discuss or how they communicate. The National Labor Relations Act protects some types of speech. At the same time, there’s no right to free speech in private workplaces. The First Amendment doesn’t apply there.

And practically speaking, employees don’t like to work where they’re micromanaged.

“Without diversity of thought, what do you have?” says Ryan Denehy, CEO of Electric.

Instead of telling employees what not to say, leaders want to encourage and give tips on how to have workplace conversations that are:

  1. Respectful. Take time to listen to and consider others’ views. Give them space and opportunities to share insights. Ask for clarification and data points to increase understanding – not to question others’ thinking.
  2. Calculated. It’s critical to control emotions when talking about sensitive subjects. Avoid impulsive or emotional responses. Try counting to five or 10 before responding.
  3. Timely. Most subjects and issues pass as others rise. Employees want to avoid rehashing things that can’t be changed. It wastes time, thought and goodwill.
  4. Fluid. Employees won’t likely solve the sensitive issues – such as the political and societal ones Basecamp banned – that come up. Sensitive issues aren’t clear cut. Employees want to accept where colleagues stand as much as they want to be respected for where they stand – especially as time and attitudes change.
  5. Agreeable. Recognize when you’re at a sticking point – and agree to disagree. It’s OK to have different views on issues, especially when you work in a psychologically safe space. It’s not OK to only see yours as the right one.
Share

Further Reading

  • Politics at Work: An Election-Season Toolkit for HR Leaders

    Employers everywhere are bracing for one of the trickiest challenges of the year as the country goes through another contentious election season. Inflammatory political speech in the workplace is disruptive and can lead to a host of workplace issues ranging from frustration and fractured relationships to claims of harassment and workplace violence incidents. With increasing […]

  • Are You Keeping Workforce Data Longer Than You Need To?

    When an employee leaves, HR closes the personnel file, processes the final paycheck, and shuts off system access. Copies of that employee’s information can remain in places HR does not manage: email archives, collaboration platforms, badge-access logs, fleet telematics systems, and the files of recruiting, payroll and benefits vendors. Some of those records have to […]

  • Your Workplace Policies Are Only as Strong as the Managers Applying Them

    A manager’s everyday conversations with employees are where an organization’s policies are tested, especially in difficult scenarios that test manager readiness. An employee may ask why they earn less than a colleague, say a coworker’s comment made them uncomfortable, or request flexibility because of a health issue. No one is fully prepared for these moments, […]