Skip to main content

Court Rulings

96 items

What does the new affirmative action ruling mean for DEI programs?

Front and center among a small slew of bombshell U.S. Supreme Court holdings that emerged last week was this one: Race-based admissions systems in higher education are unconstitutional – and thus prohibited. “Eliminating racial discrimination means eliminating all of it,” the Court’s majority memorably pronounced, while finding that both Harvard College and the University of […]

Get ready: Supreme Court raises the bar on religious accommodation duty

As we predicted, the U.S. Supreme Court has expanded the duty of employers to provide religious accommodation to employees under Title VII. The high Court did so via a unanimous decision that essentially redefines the concept of “undue hardship” in cases involving religious accommodation. Beginning immediately, employers must be prepared to do more to accommodate […]

What is job ‘fractioning’ – and why should you care?

An unpublished court ruling says that “employers may not circumvent Title VII protections by ‘fractioning’ an employee’s job.” Huh? Let’s explain what the court meant by job “fractioning” in the context of the case – and why it’s important for employers to understand the idea. Carolyn Spears became a full-time faculty member at Louisiana College […]

Balancing Title VII rights: Religious worker fired for refusing to use trans co-worker’s pronouns

In recent months, companies have faced an increasing number of lawsuits that stemmed from opposing political views, from face masks and company dress codes to “woke” training and anti-bias initiatives. In this case, the company juggled Title VII rights involving religious views and gender identities. Here’s what happened: Religious beliefs clash with preferred pronouns In […]

Employee: ‘Anti-bias training clashes with my religious beliefs’

What should an employer do if an employee says anti-bias training clashes with their religious beliefs? A new federal appeals court ruling backed an employer’s decision to terminate an employee who presented that objection and refused to attend the training. The employee did not show the termination decision was unlawfully discriminatory, the court said, and […]

Is teacher eligible for unemployment? He was fired for calling students ‘idiots’

Finding a school district failed to prove a fired teacher committed willful misconduct, a Pennsylvania court affirmed a ruling that determined the teacher was not ineligible for unemployment compensation (UC). The school district in this case had an employee code of conduct that, among other things, prohibited inappropriate comments to colleagues and teachers. In August […]

State supreme court: PIP termination violated state law

Iowa’s highest court ordered a school district to reinstate a fired teacher who had been placed on a performance improvement plan (PIP) and remanded her case to the district court for further proceedings. After receiving an unsatisfactory classroom evaluation, a Spanish teacher was put on a performance improvement plan (PIP) as required by Iowa law. […]

Seventh Circuit rejects reverse discrimination claim: Why white employee’s claim fails

The Seventh Circuit affirmed the dismissal of a white employee’s reverse discrimination claim. William Groves is a white athletic director who worked at the district for years. In 2017, he applied to serve as Corporation Director of Athletics. The superintendent, who is Black, interviewed four applicants. Groves was one of the candidates. But Groves “interviewed […]